Thirty years? Forty years? Fifty?
How long has this war on liberals gone on in TEC?
Yet, always and evermore, our liberal leadership - and I'm not speaking of the politicians in the pointy hats, but the actual leadership - gets it wrong. I understand a decade or two, but this is ridiculous.
You can't keep treating vicious and dishonest people with honor. They have none, and they don't deserve to be treated as if they do. You can't "debate," you can't "focus on the issues" because there are no issues, any longer. The objections by "orthodox" have been answered, again and again, thoroughly and publicly. This is not about "issues" but about propaganda. There are no "issues" in the lurid lies about pedophiles and bestiality still propagated by the right-wing. There's no "issue" about proper procedure in a naked attempt to strip TEC's laity and parish clergy of participation in deciding its direction. These are attacks and our charming-but-ineffectual-turn-the-other-cheek liberals are arguing with the bombs and bullets coming at them.
It's not turning the other cheek, but turning a blind eye in the name of a misguided view of Christian ministry. I used to think it was just laziness, but I'm not certain, now. I think they're like Henry Blake in MASH, distracted, basically genial, and completely incapable of recognizing the need to clamp down on elements like Margaret and Frank. Maybe, even more, they are like parents we've known, so damaged by their own parents, that they are consumed by self-doubt, tormented by indecision, and so let the bully-child torment and drive away the quiet child, all the while in a pitiable state because they, the parents, have no confidence in their authority or rightness. The result is the same: chaotic harm to those they are supposed to love, but the right and the left; the right because they are allowed to continue running their scam with a degree of honor that is in opposition to their goals and methods, the left in a far more obvious manner. Words like "discipline," "deposition," "excommunication" all result in horror and a shunning of those who suggest them. Well, I'm ready to be the BAD GUY, because someone has to if we are to survive.
I don't mind holding these "orthodox" protesters up to ridicule because that's all their views deserve. They are not arguing from a logically-held position and know it. They are attempting to manipulate a sound-bite-oriented public (which has been the public since the printing press) and instill emotional, irrational response. A sound-bite-oriented public will not respond equally to a reasoned argument! This is along the lines of a child frightened of the boogeyman because of what a malicious sibling has been telling them. Explain physics, if you like, it won't help until you show them the closet is empty, the monster is a joke, and discipline the sibling for frightening them so it won't continue. The Public is a creature in and of itself, a very powerful and unthinking creature. Yes, you can reach each individual heart and mind in time, and, while you are attempting that, The Public is going to stampede right over you, leaving something that looks like wet, bloody tissue paper.
I've heard the arguments, a Jesus, meek and gentle as a lamb, and every bit as unreal as the Roaring God On High of the "orthodox." Jesus said to treat unrepentant sinners as tax-collectors and sinners, and Jesus did - indeed! - eat and socialize with tax-collectors and sinners, but, and this is crucial, He did so to teach them and to bring them back, and didn't consider them disciples until the time they repented. Sorry, but that's how it is. The "it's-all-good" Jesus is a product of a liberal Cloud-Cuckoo Land. He held out His hand to everyone just as they were - but expected change. Jesus did say to turn the other cheek, but a whip of cords, however you want to soften it, is a tool used to drive thieves, attackers, and even animals away, and He used it at the Temple. He always held out the teaching to bring repentance and change, but did not hold out the promise of Oneness without repentance. He held out hope to the world, but chose his disciples carefully - and that's what the Church is; it's that inner circle, the disciples, not the whole undifferentiated mass of the world. Jesus forgave, but Judas still died.
There is no Love in a relationship that carries no expectation. There is no Love, because that is not a relationship.
Here's the view of The Episcopal Church I see:
Within a few years, we will have been thrown out of the Anglican Communion because we were deemed to be too troublesome. We won't, of course, "want to make waves," so we'll meekly bow our heads. We won't want to "sink to their level" so we won't give our detractors the public hiding they need, and The Public won't listen to rational argument. We'll lose those who are terrified of "going it alone" and joined to be a Rome-without-a-Pope. The idea of establishing a new communal relationship will be too much work for our leadership, who will argue that they don't want to antagonize Canterbury with who they wish to "eventually" reestablish cordial relations. The liberal leadership will, typically, accept this without criticism - because that's "mean" and "arrogant" - and this indecision will fail to bring anyone back and encourage more to leave. An outreach to a more progressive aspect of society will toss all babies out with the bathwater and the aging hipsters who have derailed the beauty of worthy Tradition will drive out those who, like me and most I know personally, are liberals with a strong ethos and theology of traditional worship. At this point, it will be a church of elderly hippies, even more elderly bishops, and those kids who have not yet gotten old enough to say, "No, I'm not going to church this Sunday." The GLBT community will have long ago deserted TEC - those not drawing a salary from a parish, at least - because TEC was "committed" to their rights only so far as it required no real sacrifice - even being thrown out was a passive thing, a decision made by others.
Ever been to one of those churches that immediately fills you with pity and horror? One of those churches with those desperately - and I mean desperately - friendly handful of late-middle-agers and one or two sullen teens? One of those churches that your heart says "This church is dying?"
Get used to it. That's what TEC will be within my lifetime unless those of us with the strength to be the BAD GUY step over and around the current liberal leadership, wavering and self-doubting, filled with just enough psychology and philosophy to undermine conviction, and tell them "Thank you. We'll take it from here. Get somewhere safe, close your eyes and stop your ears and when it's cleaned up we'll call you back out to your altars and committees and newsletters." We BAD GUYS, who aren't afraid to mock the ridiculous, to punish the criminal-in-intent-if-not-action, who aren't afraid of words like "reject," "discipline," "excommunicate," will do the dirty work and then retire to let the GOOD GUYS come back and smile and take the warmth and credit, as we BAD GUYS are remembered with loathing, shunned as much as any orthodite - because we love TEC and all of you enough to do it. If we just will do it and take the reins from those who've failed in wartime.
7 comments:
The CoE will actually be in the same position. You just need to look at the attendance figures, the current age profile and the opinion polls that show time and time again that it's largely the older people who are rigidly prejudiced.
Actually, I have some hope that this will work in our favour, shameful political fudge though it is - in order to attract more people, they will simply have to give up the prejudice, or they'll be signing their own death warrant.
Come to think of it - they may just be stupid enough to do that.
Don't you sometimes get the feeling that God is deliberately letting the church die so he can start breathing life into society anew in another way?
Certainly, I'm not too worried about the church imploding. It has so little to do with what Christ is about, that there's no point in clinging on to it.
I feel, increasingly, that you have a very good point, Erika.
I fight, not for anglicanism, but because The Episcopal Church has beauty and depth in much of it's ritual - and I believe ritual and liturgy to be of extreme importance in corporate worship - and in the most reflective and objective of its theology and for its place as a visible sign of God as socially-engaged. I love it for the people it has brought into my life. If those things could be preserved, TEC and the WWAC could . . . and the donkey they rode in on. The secular organizations are - frankly - mainly made up of angry jackasses and the same hippy "if-it's-novel-it's-better" mentality that I despise in the churches.
Maybe, Christianity will have to die so that the Body of Christ can be resurrected.
"Oh FRANK....for a moment I thought you had a CHIN!"
And I absolutely agree with you on this point of beauty in worship Mark, that's something that has to be preserved, and pray keep the politics out of it.
I cannot understand how the elderly leadership of both the C of E and RCC cannot "get with it" and figure this out. The young (and at heart) could give a rat's a** about what goes on in the privacy of one's home, and at the same time crave for a worship experience that underlies the mystical beauty that comprises of what we don't know about God. They just don't get it, and their stubbornness is just plain denial
Bradley,
I love your responses - largely because you generally agree. This is helpful! :D
Seriously thinking about the entirety of your post, though, I've come to think that, perhaps, the laity and the hierarchy in those specific churches are working in two different directions. The laity are there because of a spiritual need, which, in some way, is served in the aesthetic of liturgical worship, and, probably, in the connection with generations who've gone before. The hierarchy, though, is concerned with control - a firm, sincere, and absolutely self-serving drive to keep control. To them, liturgy is negotiable, insofar as it doesn't serve to enhance their power and control over the laity and "lower orders." Theirs is a sincere belief, I say, because they do believe God's Will is manifest in the establishment of a hierarchy with near-absolute power. It's self-serving because, it being their personal power, they either cannot or will not examine the basis of claims of episcopal "divine right." We've seen activist priests - more in CofE than RCC, as promotion is more likely there for an activist priest - become a bishop, and, suddenly, the hierarchy and order through the "proper channels" becomes a profoundly important consideration.
I can't disagree with you about those who attain the hierarchy get intoxicated with power. It is a certainty in the RCC, and seems to be with a handful of bishops in the C of E as well. And yes, anybody who's been going to the once every three year party of TEC (the same ones usually!) that this is the case as well. I just love to watch them latch onto the latest piece and justice referendum to make themselves feel good about themselves.
But what frustrates me is that some brakes had to be put on the Episcopal Church in it's continual quest for politically-correct dumbing-downness, then the camel's back was broken by us LGBT types. That hurt. We weren't the ones with the continual revisions of the prayer book back in the 1970's. We weren't the ones denouncing (and having ecclesiastical court trials thereof) of the Philly 11, then jumping on the WO bandwagon, after it became official. And then VIM, Decade of Evangelism, Hip-Hop Masses, U2charists and God know what else. This is what gives "liberals" of which I consider myself one as well, a bad name. Always trying to re-invent the wheel, if not to justify our jobs, to keep us busy with silly work.
I guess I see improvement. In my cathedral, which has been Rite Version 3.25 for too long, with a very good (but liturgically abysmal) dean is starting to come around to acknowledging the real altar (the huge limestone and marble thing that sits unused beneath the east window) and weekly evensong is surpassing the "jazzerservice" (0915 "Contemporary Eucharist) in attendance. I think the 1970's crowd is coming around to finally being able to tap into the thirst of the Gen X and Gen Y crowd (although the superbowl was a proud baby-boomer stage of denial, with the denture set of "The Who").
I think offering beautiful worship with an intellectually stimulating offering of liberation theology will be the ultimate salvation for the Episcopal Church in this era of hate filled "Butler buildings" mega-churches that dot the countryside (and I do mean country, they're in every small and medium town in Ohio these days, 'preying' on the unemployed, poor and academically challenged). It's our only hope against the emergence of a "Christian Taliban" in the United States and will be a proud stand for the elegance of Anglicanism over here.
England will have to sort out their problems this week, and I think the movers and shakers in their synod are going to come around. I don't have much faith, but what little I have, I think will work there.
It is embarrassing, the liturgical novelties.
To a large extent, I find it embarrassing because it's laziness. They want the "quick fix" that will bring the young people flocking into the churches. What they don't realize is that those are fads - nothing goes out of style more quickly than the ultra-modern.
Unfortunately, the aging hippie/hipster mindset is such that anything that smells of tradition means forced conformity. There's still the bitter anger of adolescence which drives a desire to cut all ties to the undifferentiated mass of "what-went-before." Baby/bath-water scenario ensues, and, despite peace and love talk, they are just as prone to stubbornness and outrage at being corrected as any fundie. From personal experience, the same liberals who talk so sweetly of absolute respect and tolerance for our enemies - whoops, I mean our brothers and sisters who don't get it yet - will turn quite vicious and intolerant when a fellow liberal doesn't buy that line! They'll move heaven and earth to keep an orthodite in the pews, but, if a liberal says to let 'em go, that liberal is told he has no place in their tolerant and loving church!
That's the basic mindset which is the problem in leadership and liturgical disasters like clown and hip-hop masses. It's a way of keeping power while not being willing to do the work and take the risks, either as a simple servant-of-the-servants or as the BAD GUY who does things like the squares do.
I am friends with a lot of these young folks they are trying to get in. They don't want clowns - they'll go to the circus - they don't want hip-hop - they'll download to their mp3's. Jazz, the same. For a peace rally or politically-correct seminar on personal space and gender issues, they'll seek those out. Acoustical guitar and tambourines, the sa . . . well, most go to laugh at that, anyway. It's a novelty. They know it's a novelty. They've seen the show, and it wasn't good enough to come back for.
What they want is to understand. They want to be taught, before they go in the door, what it is that they are supposed to be getting. It's true, traditional masses or services don't draw a lot of young people - because they don't want to waste time on something they have not been told about. They'll come for the novelty of "special masses," but they see the novelty and not the message. We treat our Holy Things lightly, so, at best, they're embarrassed for us.
Church was, and should be, a sanctuary - not a museum, mind! - but a sanctuary from the noise surrounding our everyday lives, into which we can take that sanctuary, that silence. We see meditation as just another peace-justice-one-world activity, rather than nourishment. We have no real catechesis to explain the symbolism and the depth of the liturgy. We've lost our holiness, our sacredness. In seeking Justice and Peace, we've settled for justice and peace, because it's easier, with no mystery.
Maybe we don't explain it to them, not because we can't reach them outside the parish or don't want to, but because we don't know what it means either . . . and that's not the liturgy's fault.
Post a Comment