Saturday, December 5, 2009

Cultural Christian

I had run into the expression "Cultural Jew" and found it fascinating.

Basically put, and with the caveat of it being my understanding in this paraphrase, cultural Judaism operates from a default of Judaic law and commentary, but with the active application of ongoing intellectual and spiritual understanding on a personal level.

Now, if I'm presenting a concept that's already been presented, I put it down to a wanting education, but, I think the concept of a cultural Christian might apply to me. I start from the default of Scripture and Tradition, but those cannot be overarching concerns, they are not the final arbiter. The reason for this is simple: I believe what Jesus promised. Now, for most people, it seems all that is remembered is the promise of some Apocalyptic return, but the most important promise to me, is that each of us would be sent the Advocate, the Spirit, whatever you call it, to guide us. This clearly indicates that we were expected to exercise a discernment far more important than "check the book then check with grandpa." That, to me, is far more trivial and ridiculous than any serious engagement that questions the (pre)suppositions of archaic formularies. How, I would ask, can God live, if the living God in us isn't that God? I'm not avoiding the concept of egoic self-will and evil - I've written a lot on them on mine and others' blogs - but God lives into a changing and evolving universe and is part of that as well as transcending it, and we are a part of Him, and He a part of us. God is immanent, as well as transcendant, so He must express Himself within the changes of understanding and environment, as well. Without that, we can say, quite clearly, the Incarnation had no meaning! Without meaning to the Incarnation, without a participatory God, the Resurrection means nothing. Our faith had been in vain.

The exercise of this cultural Christianity does not happen in isolation. I reject or accept things for myself, it's true, but I also am conscious of the community. If it were simply my conviction that homosexuality is not inherently disordered (and the inherent is an important part), then I would limit that belief to me. But, I have found this belief to have far wider expression, and to have far greater objective backing than that which I had found. I've spoken on my problems with WO, but I found myself re-evaluating in community, and, finally, personally, as well. As a Christian, I must accept that a wrong-doing against me is a minor thing, and can act or not act as I see fit, but wrong-doing against a group, even a smallish group of which I am a part, calls for me, as a Christian, to exercise whatever abilities I have to establish justice. The trope is "there is no such thing as a Christian in isolation" but there is no such thing as Christianity in isolation, as well. We are not a tribe, or a chosen people but a force in the entirety of humanity, working for all humanity's salvation. We've constantly interfered, but rarely participated in that salvation. We seem to be willing to limit "help" to Christians. To me, this is bizarre, and I can no more accept that Christian charity, compassion and goodwill is limited to Christians than I can accept that those people arguing that limitation as valid are truly Christian! It's impossible. It's outside of possibility, or, again, Jesus came for absolutely nothing.

That is why I believe that there can be no final appeal to Scripture and Tradition - these are dead things, dead because they stand apart. In the absence of harm, and certainly in the evidence of their giving comfort and stability, they are to be embraced, but their suppositions and position must never be given sacrosanct quality, or we strip God of the humanity He endured so much to achieve.

3 comments:

Erika Baker said...

Amen!!

But there CAN be an appeal to Scripture, it just depends on whether you focus on the individual examples given there, which are necessarily out of their own time and culture, or whether you focus on the values they proclaim.

And, of course, those who see things rigidly are precisely also cultural Christians in that they are steeped in a modern mind set that cannot handle the nuance, complexity and mysticism of ancient texts but insists on pinning everything down in a supposedly rational black and white. They just don't realise that their stance is as deeply individualistic as they criticise ours to be.

M.McShea said...

Christianity does sometimes operate in insolation, in a cave or a desert and then lines get rewritten somewhere. There's no copyright on the title Cultural Christian as far as I know. Use it. Lose it.
Welcome to the club. There are no rulebooks. What comes forth from the divine spark within is hopefully born of spirit or soul and in conjunction of your search for truth (within a Christian context of course).

MarkBrunson said...

Thank you for the responses.

It's given me thoughts with which to refine my view and its expression.