Tuesday, November 3, 2009

Thought For The Day

Because I've heard several times in the last couple of days how great he is:

No.

C. S. LEWIS SUCKS!!!!

Yea, verily, Brethren he sucketh.

The Once and Future suck.

Has, have, had sucked.

He was a dreadful man, with a dreadful theology and a view that held Mankind in such utter contempt that it would've taken Augustine of Hippo aback. He had less understanding of God, Mercy, or Compassion than he did of humanity or psychology and he had zero understanding of those things. His writing is like being hit on the head with a Bible covered in cute, furry animals. He was, face it, a born-again Christian, and they are about as grounded and capable of rational thought as a street pigeon - people who profoundly screwed up their own lives and those around them, suddenly found themselves paying for it, and "got religion" using it as a talisman to ward off further mishap, and a weapon to force others to submit to their beliefs.

Yes, I can forgive his dismal, self-hating theology and his utterly preposterous and cancerous views on human nature, women, and homosexuals because people in that time were ignorant, profoundly ignorant, and a lot has changed since then. Forgiving that doesn't mean we should celebrate and elevate his ignorance and - frankly - piss-poor writing to the level of theology.

7 comments:

Wormwood's Doxy said...

And yet...

The Great Divorce managed to undo 15 years of fundagelical brainwashing and eliminate my fear of Hell. (The belief in it got eliminated a little later, but St. Clive started the process.)

For that alone, he will always have my undying gratitude.

Cheers,
Doxy

P.S. But I loved this line: His writing is like being hit on the head with a Bible covered in cute, furry animals. Bwahahahaha!!!

MarkBrunson said...

I'm a great believer in the stopped clock theory of fundamental truth, so I know there are people who've taken a great deal away from C. S. -- I'm not one of them, and don't believe that he deserves the reputation he's gotten. The Amityville Horror stopped me believing in haunted houses, but that doesn't mean it's great writing of accomplished what Jay Anson meant for it to.

I respect what you're saying, though.

Not him, no, but what you're saying, yeah. :D

MarkBrunson said...

"..or accomplished what Jay Anson meant for it to."

Erika Baker said...

When I first found faith I read every single book he wrote. I liked the accessible way he spoke of his faith, and it was an excellent exercise to work out what I might agree with and what not. Needless to say, I agreed with very very very little, but I'm still grateful for his books - at least they were the right challenge at the right time.

And I'm with Doxy - His writing is like being hit on the head with a Bible covered in cute, furry animals - is one of the best lines ever!

Kay & Sarah said...

I am not a C.S. Lewis fan either. He has quite a following and I don't understand it. He was a radio announcer and he seems to write like a radio announcer talks. He just fills a lot space with with words.....like a radio announcer when they need to fill air time.

I would prefer having a root canal and a mammogram rather than have to read C.S. Lewis.

MarkBrunson said...

Again, I'm not saying other people haven't gotten anything from the books - hell, so did I. I read them and said, "If this doofus is considered a theologian, the Church needs me to stay and help it out!"

Two Auntees,

I am so glad I'm not the only one.

Unknown said...

All the evil characters in his books are 'dark foreigner' types. I don't know if I want my children to read books that have evil so identifiable.