Saturday, October 4, 2008

Depressing and Completely In Character

Now our neo-con friends have made a movie - no, not the execrable garbage Fireproof (produced by a vehemently anti-gay church here in my own town) - but An American Carol

Read some of the user comments. It's telling. The usual bully complex of the neo-cons - tough when in numbers "We're the American majority!" and pathetic and self-pitying when stood up to "We're soooo alone in Hollywood! Everybody mistreats us!"

Feh!

And, yes, Airplane was funny . . . but it wasn't trying to "say" anything and was made to appeal to people looking to suspend their intellect and just laugh. The fact that so many of the neo-con commenters compared Carol favorably to Airplane also backs up the bully hypothesis by showing a sophomoric level of political "commentary" is about their speed.

I don't like Michael Moore, and he doesn't do what he does for any reason other than to make money and build his fame, but, at least he shines a light on real corruption, and doesn't feel the need to make up tales with ghosts and uneven comparisons. He allows the people he lampoons to carry their own petard.

The part that makes me sad is the number of actors I liked and had admired who I will now be unable to support because of their involvement in this film and the rabid neo-con streak it shows in them.

Robert Davi
Kelsey Grammer
James Woods
Leslie Nielson
Jon Voight

I'm sorry that I'll never be able to watch one of your films again.

UPDATE:

Since I have received a personal note from one of the above-mentioned actors (and, yes, I'm quite willing to accept him at his word), I want to add a few things.

NOTE: I am not calling for a boycott of these actors! They are fine actors, very accomplished and talented. The worker deserves his wages and these are excellent workers! Even if I thought I had the pull or audience to call for such a thing, I would never call for the shunning, either professionally or socially of any individual. I am sure that they are decent, likeable people with good intentions, as well.

What I am stating here is my profound disappointment, even heartbreak, over seeing actors that I admire and follow actively supporting a regime, a world-outlook, which harms me and mine, which minimizes my humanity, strips me of my dignity and leaves me alone and threatened. Mr. Davi, you speak of feeling isolated in Hollywood . . . imagine how it would be to feel isolated, hated and threatened, physically as well as professionally in relation to your entire nation. I'm afraid that, actually, I am extremely conservative with a liberal outlook, and part of that conservativism is a deep distrust of my fellow man when in groups. I believe in the slippery slope, and when my most conservative acquaintances tell me that forced therapy, concentration camps, secret police, the illegalization of protest could never happen here, I tell them "It hasn't happened yet."

SECOND: I see in my writing that I have minimized the concern and alienation that these artists feel in their own community, and, as I despise it when I see others engage in such dismissals, I apologize. It was out of line and if you feel insecure, that is a call for my compassion, not my sarcasm.



3 comments:

Anonymous said...

Dear Mark,,this is Robert Davi ,,I have read your comment about American Carol and your reaction.
Please permit me a response ,, if one of my friends or an actor I like happens to do a film that has an extreme left wing point of view or any that I do not agree with , I can watch objectively , appreciating the performance, and the film, even though I may not agree with the message in that film. Also ,since the majority of my fellow actors are left leaning I guess I do not even think about their politics.i do not let that come into play in my enjoying their work .I do get excited if i find out someones whose work I respect is a conservative because there are so few ,at least who admit it . It is saddening to me that you have had such a reaction, others may as well..I believe that we are all connected, all brothers and sisters the left and right of us the straight or gay ,we have our differences like in every family but what is important is the freedom for each of us to be who we are without fear while at the same time respecting each other . I hope you can get beyond the politics and still enjoy the work
perhaps one day we may meet and have a more in depth conversation .all the best, Robert Davi

MarkBrunson said...

Mr. Davi - Robert,

I want you to understand that I'm not condemning you or the others - I understand that you feel you are doing a very good thing.

However, from my point of view, to glorify war and the Bush administration is wrong on a profound level. I can watch films that portray most anything, but those that glorify horror I have to speak out against. I will never have anything to do with an Eli Roth film because his Hostel films are simply snuff films packaged as horror. I believe Michael Moore has become self-serving and lost a moral center. I speak against his films, as well.

You say you believe we are connected - these are beautiful words, but you must understand, Robert, that that is what I'm saying, too. The easiest point of departure for me is the "gay thing" since I am gay. You may not agree with the neo-con view on homosexuality, but by supporting them on these other issues, you are supporting them on that issue, as well.

I can't really explain my feelings on the war in Iraq. That would take a book. It is far more than an ivory tower belief that war is wrong, but a firm religious conviction, a practical consideration, and, most of all, a consideration of this particular war. For myself, I believe it is better for me to die than to kill, but I cannot extend that belief to others around me.

I am touched and honored that you came and spoke with me here, Robert. It was kind. I hope I have responded in a way that makes my view clear in as inoffensive a way as possible. Please, feel free to contact me at any time via email (there is a link in my profile).

I wish you all the best.

Mark Brunson

Anonymous said...

I think we all have a little mental list of the glitterati who are right-wingers. It disgusts me but only rarely keeps me from laughing at their jokes or appreciating their talent. I wouldn't want to hang out with them, but as long as I'm paying for cable anyway... I would not, however, pay for a movie or theater ticket for any on my list.

I vote with my dollars.