Friday, July 11, 2008

Clinical Depression

It astounds me that there is still so little real awareness of what clinical depression is and what it does. We know it's out there, but there is no real understanding of it, as evidenced by the reactions of well-meaning friends, the guidance given to our clergy, the prescriptions of our doctors, and the often pointless therapies taught to our psychiatric community.

J. K. Rowling said that she drew the idea of the Dementors - horrifying creatures that suck the joy, and, eventually, the souls out of their victims - from depression. It is a wonderful image of situational depression, which most people experience in some degree, but woefully inadequate to give an understanding of clinical depression. Asking "What triggered it?" or "What's making you upset?" are pointless questions, unhelpful, even harmful. There is no "what" that triggered it -- it simply happens. Trying to fix it, pointing out the "bright side" of life is as useless, and, frankly, offensive as trying to fix the death of a friend's loved one, or saying, "Hey! At least you didn't die!" If you try to understand it from that analogy, you might understand the depressed person's irrational behavior, irrational anger at what you think is an attempt to help.

You can't fix it. It seems like madness because, in a sense, it is. The rational landscape is upside down. There is no perception of an objective reality, but the mirror of perception is turned inward, completely darkened, able to neither accept nor reflect light from outside.

We - the clinically depressed - understand both Grace and eternal damnation in a way more direct than most.

Imagine you are in a dark, deep, stifling place, more cavernous than a pit, though, perhaps, the Pit, might be descriptive. Far above, almost beyond the reach of sight, is the light of the upper world you've left. There is a ladder stretching back to the light, but is is broken and unsteady, miles long, and you are too tired, exhausted in mind and body.

You are at the beginning of the depression.

In your exhaustion, there is only one way to go - further down, for the downward-spiralling way is broad and easy. It leads you down to a swirling Emptiness -- not the ever-potential of the Ground of Being, but a hellish soup, unable to take healthy form, but distorted forms and visions erupt in it. Every smile becomes a mocking, every pause in conversation a disgusted rejection -- here, the clinically depressed see Hell, for it is completely selfish, completely inward, completely subjective and born of hate; it is the hate of self and other that unafflicted psychologies can repress and pretend is not there - but I assure you, it is. We see it in ourselves, and we are no different from you save by an unhappy glitch in the wet-wiring. Be glad there is no sorcery to give outward form to the things that giggle and mock in that noxious swirling abyss, because no Lovecraft, no King, no del Toro ever came up with monstrosities like these, that, if they could walk among us, would turn the world inside out, to an empty shell, a shattered Qlippothic wasteland. Why? Because, in that depth of the depression, we want you to feel our pain. I said it was selfish, and that's what hell is; hell is not other people, but yourself, ever inward-looking, seeing only yourself and your disappointments and pains, and that, if you see it, is that Chaos-maelstrom the clinically depressed mind descends to. You've come too far to go back up -- there is no "up" for you now -- but you can't stay. When you stay, the deviant mockeries take over, and we see what happens in their human forms, most often with those bland, self-satisfied people who find circumstances spinning out of control - the extremis of situational depression - without whatever natural protection the inevitable descent of the clinically depressed mind provides. What walks the earth, then, is horrible enough in human guise.

The only way out, is down, into the waiting, dusty, breathless darkness, absolute darkness without bond, without reverberation -- without the vital spark. Descend, descend into a lifeless universe, not just god-forsaken, but with no god to have ever been forsaken by. What can we say about this darkness, this long-tomb-walk? Darkness doesn't signify. It is Utter Void, in which even the mind perceiving it becomes calcified and immovable; no observer, no object, but no unity. Just nothingness. Those who never leave here take the way of the noose, or the bullet, or the razor-blade or the pill. Almost none who come here leave without a piece of it, and find what chemicals or habits or nervous hobbies drive away that little piece that lives in them -- if live is the word for it. After a while, in this place - and there is no quick way through - there are no tears, no sighs, for those things have more life than this place could support.

But for those who stumble all the way through Hell:

The Shining Uncreatedness - not nothingness, but No-thing-ness, which is all potential, all beauty, all goodness. It is the hospital of the Hell-battered heart, the soft, silent/potent embrace of the Ground of Being Who has, you now realize, always been there on this nightmare journey. In that silent Ground of Silence, there are wordless words which tell of things you forgot at birth. They heal you, though not without scars, but only stay as minute reflexes of the mind which carry you through the next downward descent, which - it turns out - is not to Below, but to the Center.

And this is Grace.

Most, I think, take their well-deserved rest here -- only very few seek out the lips that whisper the words of the Shining Uncreatedness, and those few become the great saints, and buddhas, and bodhisattvas, for no man may live who sees the face of God, and they return, ego-dead but Self-alive and never have to take the downward/Center journey again.

After a time, the Shining Uncreatedness gives way to a place, an opening with the stone rolled back. Here is a world new and unspoilt, just for that moment of arising, a world cleansed and fresh -- just for that one moment -- and then . . .

chop wood, carry water - except for those few who saw the Face, and will never go back and need not, and who Chop Wood! Carry Water! laughing and free.

Perhaps, if understood, in that instant of return, our clergy would ask us what we've seen and what we see, rather than nervously demurring. Friends would stay by and wait, speaking words of guidance and hope, rather than platitudes or the fearful/resentful withdrawal.

Perhaps, we could learn, be trained to bring back more than the scars and the grinding certainty of that next downward trip, make a discipline and true practice of it, rather than see it as a hindrance, or stumbling block to practice.

This is my experience of clinical depression, albeit in symbol and hastily-constructed picture. Take it for what you may take from it, though I doubt many will ever read it.

8 comments:

Anonymous said...

There is a book called The Depression Advantage that is about spiritual growth and the role that depression can play in it. Based on your writing about visiting hell and the potential to come back a saint, I think you will love it. The website is www.depressionadvantage.com

The saints that faced depression made the journey many times even after their realization, but felt that the pain was nothing compared to the realizations that it afforded them.

Anonymous said...

Thanks for writing this.

MarkBrunson said...

Anonymous,

Thank you. I'll take a look at the website!

MarkBrunson said...

Lindy,

I'm glad you found it meant something to you.

My experience has been that there's really no understanding of what we're experiencing, and that it is almost impossible to convey in mere technical terms or the everyday speech of simple deep unhappiness.

J Kempf said...

I think you have managed to capture here the horror, the beauty, and the arrogance of depression.

I love you.

June Butler said...

Mark, I read this post before I left to travel, and I did not have time to reply. I understand a bit more about clinical depression than I did before, and it is truly a terrible illness. I have been through situational depression a few times, and while that is not fun, it is nothing like what you describe.

I now know what bromides not to speak to those with the malady. I've probably said some of those very things to you in the comments here. I hope I won't repeat the mistake.

You seem to be out of the worst of it, and I'm glad for that. It sounds like pure hell.

Love and prayers to you.

MarkBrunson said...

Mimi,

Well, I'm out of the worst of it . . . for this time around.

It is Hell, but you come through stronger, so there's some benefit to be derived, if you look for it.

Having read your posts on your trip, I saw that you had a few unexpected difficulties, and a bit of your own situational depression.

Is everything well now? How are you doing?

June Butler said...

Mark, I am well, thank you.

Thanks be to God and to your own perseverance that you came out of the pit stronger. You're right about learning the meaning of grace and redemption in the midst of the toughest times. I need God for my salvation each day of my life for my very survival. That's knowing what grace is.

As for the sweet-bye-and-bye, that will take care of itself. I hardly give it a thought.