For those who've responded to my question about bishops -
THANK YOU, THANK YOU, THANK YOU!
I'm so sorry that I haven't had the chance to write, until now.
For those who don't know:
I only have computer access Mon-Fri nights, so I rarely, if ever, get the chance to even check the blog on the weekend, and, when I do have access, it is at work. Given that my employer is so kind, I take pains to make sure that I'm tending my job, first and foremost, which means that sitting down like this takes a bit of doing, and may not get done on busy nights.
I beg your patience.
What I'm trying to do, here, is establish what, in the mind of the TEC and the Church (by which I include all churches, congregational, RC, Anglican, Orthodox) and to see if, perhaps, we in TEC are missing something out here, or if we really are legitimately different, or, if perhaps others are missing something out.
A great deal of my concern is the accountability - reasonable accountability - of a bishop to the people, lay and clergy. I have been taken aback by the first Lambeth meeting I've ever followed, by the degree of secrecy surrounding the whole affair, and the forceful degree to which the non-bishops are being kept out -- it is unhealthy, to my thinking, and unholy. We are told by Our Lord that it is evil that is done under cover, so why must our bishops exclude us from their deliberations, even as informed observers? What reason is possibly so convincing for carrying out meetings that will affect our individual parishes in such seclusion and secrecy? Why should bishops be afraid to speak what they believe in front of the world? Isn't there something wrong, if they are unwilling to do so?
5 comments:
Well, their secrecy could be at least partly motivated by respect for the polity, i.e., recognition of their role in it, of the effect of their words on the church as a whole and on the lives of those who look to them for leadership. They may fear that if we see them wrangling, brainstorming, or whatever, some of us might lose respect, or even heart. They may want to get it "right" before showing it to us. I can understand that.
Yes, it can be seen as patronizing, but let's face it, some folks actually want, even need, to be patronized.
fs,
While I understand that, it is a business model, not a model for church. We really, really need to get out of this thinking of church as simply another managerial model. Either it's a family, with the openness and messiness of families, or it's just another social organization.
I also understand the paternal model of keeping information from the children "for their own good" -- besides the fact that it rarely does work to the child's good, no clergy can reasonably claim a parental role over-against their own calling as a brother or sister. They are the children, too.
The problem of the secrecy is that it is severely damaging -- we speak of the "weaker brethren" without considering them. The only outlets left are a commercial media, seeking to sell news and a blogosphere comprised of people as anxious - and outside - as the rest of us. The result is speculation and rumor-mongering which does incredible damage across the AC, and causes those who are already worried and defeated to give up -- I am reliably informed of at least two people I know who have left the church and are considering abandoning Christianity based on the severely restricted "information" coming out of Canterbury.
Finally, bishops shouldn't be saying anything they can't say publicly.
Your points are very well-taken, Mark. I wish those assembled at Lambeth could read and discuss them. Would you consider putting them into a letter to your own bishop? Or, if he/she isn't open enough, sending them to one who is?
I would, yes, though I really don't know which one or how to reach them.
I'm afraid that, as much as I like the man personally, Bp. Loutitt would be unlikely to do much other than glance at anything I've written. I've written him several times and received either bland responses or no response at all. My experience has been that bishops tend to be very difficult to reach, being insulated by layers of assistants, commissions, committees, offices, offices of diocesan communication, etc. How to reach any bishop is a difficult consideration.
Considering both the spontaneous nature of what I've written, so far, and my own tendency to attention deficit, I would welcome some pointers as to what might be considering worth repeating to the bishops, as well.
Within those considerations *grin* I would certainly write -- I feel more ashamed in not writing to the bishops than I do in anything I've said, even where a bit intemperate.
You could review what you've written so far on the subject, picking out the main points, the ones that you think make your case most convincingly. Then study them to decide the order in which they're best presented to your bishop. Then just let it flow: you are a strong and eloquent writer, Mark.
Post a Comment