We are, in my parish, currently using a form of canon, or Eucharistic prayer, which comes from Enriching Our Worship, which I understand to be forms under consideration as part of prayer-book reform. At the risk of sounding like the former '28-Prayer-Bookers, it's certainly not enriching worship for me.
Understand, I'm not not against reforming and redesigning the prayer book, but I am against novelty for its own sake. The difficulties are - at least - twofold. First, there is a lack of poetry to it which conducts true worship. Liturgy is not, exlusively, an act of intellect, but an engagement of senses, and liturgy written by committee is disastrous. Surely there is a better, more organic expression of our current theological understanding? The ancient liturgies are still beautiful and moving after centuries simply because they weren't designed, as such, but drawn from many sources, many epistles, theological writings and poetry. God made all equal, but He didn't make all equally good artists. Simply saying "Here; you're a good theologian and sensitive, write a liturgical prayer," is not enough. We should, must, be concerned about the artistic quality of liturgy and resist the "dumbing down" of general culture which produces the sort of greeting-card quality of eucharistic prayer we're laboring under in my parish -- it has all the poetic and soul-stirring qualities of a dishmop.
Second, there is the theological difficulty.
"It is right to give Him thanks and praise,"
becomes
"It is right to give our thanks and praise,"
making us the center of the eucharistic feast. If we're moving into a church in which this is an acceptable focus, I won't be far behind the rejectionists, I'm afraid. It continues to focus on us:
"Rising he destroyed our Death,
Rising he restored our Life,
Christ Jesus come again in glory."
Again "our" death and "our" life are the foci, and Christ Jesus feels a bit of an afterthought expressed at the end of a clumsy, lead-lump of a statement. Contrast that with:
"Christ has died.
Christ is risen.
Christ will come again."
Which gives us the focus of what's happening at the altar. Christ is the focus. We have been exhorted, preached to and prayed for up through the Peace; this is Jesus' special time and focus. In addition, the entirety of human time and experience is encapsulated in one elegant statement; all three dimensions of human timespace - has, is, and will - are contained in a bare-bones Passion narrative. The entirety of Christology is explained in essence - past incarnation, present transcendence and future coming. Christology, soteriology and eschatology are all encapsulated. Humanity is drawn into it simply by inclusion of these three common dimensions, relating us, at the same time, to Christ.
I'm sorry if you've been offended, but if we can't do better, it's better not to do.
9 comments:
it also mistranslates the words of institution.
I very much agree with you about the liturgy, but that's not why I am here.
I read your post at Jake's and just wanted to tell you that you are very much in my prayers. I can relate to both the car damage (my son damaged "my" car backing out of our garage) and the likelihood (though in my case over something else) of seriously strained or broken family relations (both sides still having difficulty with forgiveness).
I know you especially need your family. I hope and pray that they will understand how devastating this must be for you and how the relationships on both sides have to be more important than the property damage. Meanwhile, embrace your church family and others who can lend you support.
Praying that you find the strength and comfort you need,
Kathy
Like Klady, I am also here to ask you to realize that there are people praying for you, and that this will pass.
God bless you.
No Youuuuuu Didn't!!
Markus!!
Bitch you better not have taken your own life!!!
Aunt Esther waitin' to get'cha in heaven.....but personally,..I don't think you'lle make it there.
...since you have such a low regard for God giving you life.
Prayers ascending for you, Mark I.
Do not drink; do not get suicidal. If you do (either one), pick up the phone and call 911.
Suicide is a permanent solution to a TEMPORARY problem. It's just a car, it's not life and death.
Whew... another prayer-sayer heard from over here. So, not so bad in the light of day.
I also want to take note of this with you:
"Rising he destroyed our Death,
Rising he restored our Life,
Christ Jesus come again in glory."
That's a line from some of the service music we use in my mission parish - many of the parishioners are former Catholics, and for some reason they invested in a hymnal called "Gather" and stopped singing out of the '82 Hymnal. My old parish merged with them, so we're in our second year of adapting to each others' ways.
I never like singing this refrain. It's far too "memememeMEEEmememeeee" and seems a little happy-clappier than I usually go for. But the congregation loves it, so we sing it.
Have you looked at the New Zealand Prayer Book? There's some serious poetry there...
Hello. This post is likeable, and your blog is very interesting, congratulations :-). I will add in my blogroll =). If possible gives a last there on my blog, it is about the TV de LCD, I hope you enjoy. The address is http://tv-lcd.blogspot.com. A hug.
I haven't seen any of the proposed liturgies but I hope this is not an indication of things to come. Stay on the case!
I am glad to see I'm not the only one.
I knew, Thomas, that there was something wrong in the words of institution, but, being no theological scholar, I didn't know what. I do have to wonder why, in what is a sacred re-enactment, essentially, the compilers of this liturgy would feel the need for that.
Ginny, I have often heard from some very liberal Catholics coming into the Episcopal Church that they were drawn by an open and affirming faith that didn't jettison and needlessly "streamline and modernize" the liturgy. I can see it used in an "alternate" hymnal -- we've been "blessed" with one of those in our parish, as well -- as a way of adding to the expression of worship. I don't particularly like, and in a few cases detest, the hymns compiled for "St. Patrick's Favorites," but they don't jar as much as this liturgy. I've heard it said, nothing is out of date as quickly as the ultra-modern. That's always been our strength, I think, in allowing flexibility in worship, while preserving as baseline the ancient formulae. I think we would be very unwise to allow a reactionary liberalism, in response to the threat from fundamentalism masquerading as mainstream Christianity, to throw out the baby. Perhaps we should ask our Catholic converts to speak about their experience with some of the more "innovative" post-Vatican II liturgical practice!
All --
Thank you for your concern. I am well, and have come out stronger and a bit clearer about some relationships for the experience!
Post a Comment