Our lack of clarity about our position.
You may feel your knee jerking, at this point, if you are a liberal, but keep in mind I am a liberal as well.
I constantly find myself looking at these "Baptists in pretty clothes" who seem to have popped up and formed cysts within the larger Episcopal Church. I can only conclude that that has to do with a lack of clarity in our position, vis a vis catechetical training. Most "Inquirer's Classes" are dry, exceptionally perfunctory events covering a few hours, spread out over several months, with absolutely no requirement of actual retention of any of the material, were it worth retaining in any case.
Now, as a largely progressive church, we are a bit averse to forcing others to "sign on" to a belief set. That is well and good. But, we must be aware that such an aversion is part of a belief set without which, the very nature of the church we've joined and formed dies. There is no shame, no fascistic tendency in saying "These are our beliefs and positions, and, if you are to be a part of us, you must accept the applicability of these beliefs and positions to the way our church is run." Would so many of these fundamentalists, clearly looking for nothing more than more fundamentalism but with pretty vestments and a pseudo-RC "communion" have joined if we had made it clear that that is not, nor will be, what TEC is? Probably not. We are committed to a certain way, and that way is not the way of such people.
Perhaps one of our first priorities, once this brouhaha has settled, is to form an actual process for our catechumens. The Reasserters predict our death because all they see is the popular trend of fundamentalism, without looking at what we might have in common with that great-growth denomination of "none." We might have what they're looking for. We can't, as it seems Reasserters have, write them off as the unwashed masses who have no faith or stamina, but see if we, in TEC's polity and vision, don't have what they're looking for. Don't underestimate these people as all being patrons of a spiritual McDonald's (some are, certainly, and that has led to the trend in Fundamentalism); many, if not most, are willing to expend energy and to commit time for something they understand and are a part of. Why should any of the unchurched be interested in a life committment to something requiring a few desultory chats on ecclesial history, a brief meeting with a bishop they have no other knowledge of, and the promise of coffee hour?
One of our first priorities, therefore, should be a catechumenate to replace the sad little "inquirer's classes." A real period of study and requirement. It seems the recipe for meteoric falls in number, but those who are committed will come, will stay and will infuse us with the energy that led them to the committment that, apparently, so many of us had to stumble into accidentally, on our own. To that end, we need to stop with the public vs. private policy that has largely occupied our leadership, and make a few bold statements on inclusion . . . including where inclusion stops and simply becomes indulgence.
10 comments:
I think that's a good idea, Mark. While certainly not requiring anyone to sign on to a set of beliefs, it should be made clear what TEC is about and the progressive stance TEC generally takes on social and some theological issues. The apparent prevalence of what I would call "liturgical Baptists" surprised me a few years ago, and continues to surprise me, as the attitudes of the conservatives within the church (if it can be accurately taken from conservative blogs) is certainly not what I grew up with in TEC, nor did my parents.
That said, I would never want anyone to be turned away from TEC, but if their beliefs are so strongly held against what TEC stands for, then perhaps another denomination would feel more like "home" to them.
I suspect the Charismatic Episcopal Church might be a good home for some of the folks who are discontent with TEC.
Charismatic Episcopal Church
I confess that I get the same uncontrollable twitch when I see that phrase as I do when I see "liturgical dance"... ;-)
Mark--TEC actually has a very rigorous course of theological education and spiritual formation. It's called Education for Ministry, and it was the very best thing I ever did for myself. (I'm a mentor in the program now.)
The only problem is that it's a 4-year commitment, and most people blanch immediately when you tell them that. I know that my own confirmation class was woefully short (and that was 4 months!), but I wonder how you would structure a really meaningful inquirer's class? People are always moaning about how they don't have enough time...
I'd love to hear your thoughts.
Cheers,
Doxy
One of our first priorities, therefore, should be a catechumenate to replace the sad little "inquirer's classes."
A-effing-men!
Did you know that you can become an Episcopalian in the Diocese of Texas by watching a video? Yep. That's all it takes. On the plus side, it's good for the numbers.
EFM is not a solution. I've known several EFM graduates and they are idiots. They have some basic Bible knowledge but are totally unable to think theologically, if at all, and DO NOT ask them to place things in any kind of context except the one they were taught... They can't draw in information from other fields or make the kinds of connections that seem logical and easy for the rest of us. Unless it comes from the mouth of their mentor, they won't even think about it. I think EFM is a cult.
Crucuillo is a cult too.
It should take three years to become an Episcopalian... a couple more weeks for ordination. If people want to commit to that, they will. If they don't, they won't. The institutional church may dwindle down to three people. So what?
A robust catechumenate would go further towards healing the wound of ordination and status-ism (in which EFM is complicit) which currently festers like an open and stinking sore on the body of Christ than anything else I can think of.
I am on a tear about this today, I'll tell you what, because I am sick and tired of people who clearly don't know or care telling me what my church is about.
There.
And, yes, I do feel much better now thank you.
Linda Diane McMillan
Lindy---I'm sorry you have had such a bad experience with EFM graduates, but I really cannot allow your condemnation of the entire program to go unchallenged---and I take personal umbrage at your characterization of EFM as a "cult."
EFM is SUPPOSED to be theological education and spiritual formation. It is not surprising that the program would not be uniformly good. The quality of mentors varies, as it does in any group--but the ones I know (and remember that I am in generally conservative North Carolina) are a dedicated, deeply thoughtful bunch who take seriously their mission to help people learn to think theologically. We do NOT tell people what to think---we are mentors, not "teachers."
I just attended my annual recertification training, and I was deeply impressed by my colleagues' strong faith and great love for learning and asking questions. Please don't slander an entire group of people who love God and see this as our ministry.
I put in hundreds of hours over the course of a year, planning theological reflections and preparing to lead discussions on the scriptures, the history of our church and our faith, and theology. I certainly don't do it for the money---and I don't do it because it's a "cult." I do it because I believe that is God's calling for me.
Pax,
Doxy
I have to say, Lindy, that my experience with EFM has been much the same as Doxy's.
Perhaps you would be willing to share with us your experience?
On the other hand, I found Cursillo to be much as you've described. One of my fellow parishioners who attended with me, former Vietnam Special Ops said into the 2nd day, "These are all straight-out-of-the-textbook brainwashing techniques!" I didn't ask what textbook, of course, and, 10 years later, Dubya showed us all which textbook.
Anyway, to address one of your questions, Doxy, we had in our diocese, for a time, a program for training lay-catechists. I don't know the content of the course, and, at the time, saw no need to become a lay catechist. If the training is rigorous enough (and I'm not sure that the in-depth nature of EFM is exactly what's needed in catechesis), then each parish sponsoring a catechist could be very workable. One of the problems for our EFM group (I only had one year) was - more than the time committment - the expense and availability over our very spread out diocese. We couldn't keep our group going after that one year, unfortunately.
Of course, you've still got the problem of getting the prospective confirmands to commit to the time, but, maybe that's what we need; to tell them, "Look, you want to join and we want you, but you have to make this committment to do it." I'm not sure making things easier and more convenient have been particularly good for TEC, or Christianity in general.
Suzer,
You've mentioned some things that have resonated with me, and I'd like to think them over. Thank you.
Well, Mark, I already did say what my experiences were. I knew two women in my last parish who were EFM graduates. I was in one or two Bible studies with at least one of them, frequently both, every week. And they were idiots. Also, and a buddy reminded me of this, they both had very poor social skills. One hopes that they were not educated to minister among other human beings because they just didn't have it in them, Either one. There is another parish which I visited at for quite a while (several months) before I joined at the other one and there was an EFM graduate there too. Very sociable young fellow. And so arrogant that nobody would talk to him. He was very opinionated and shared his opinions very well. I think he was bright enough and maybe he did get a little education from EFM. But, he monopolized Sunday School in a most unhelpful way. Again, he wasn't really fit for ministry. Maybe it should be Education for Ego. I am not for EFM.
Wormwood, I have noticed that sometimes people do take personal umbrage when I tell them my truth. I knew when I made those comments that EFM-ers would take personal umbrage at them. That in no way changes my experience.
I also know that the bishop-ass-kissers in Texas will take personal umbrage when I say that this diocese is a cesspool of clericalism, status-ism, and stupidity. But, that does not change my own experience of it.
Shall I go on?
A robust catechumenate would go further towards healing the wound of ordination and status-ism (in which EFM and Crucillo are complicit) which currently festers like an open and stinking sore on the body of Christ than anything else I can think of.
That's my experience.
Lindy
Lindy--You've known three EFM graduates who were idiots. I accept that this is your experience.
But in the U.S., over 70,000 people have participated in the program, and over 22,000 have finished all four years. I suggest that you need to meet a few more of us before you tag us *all* as idiots, status-seekers, and cult members.
It's kind of like conservative reactionaries holding up some image of GLBTs they don't like (leathermen, BDSM, etc.) and saying "All GLBTs are like this!" They use their prejudices against the few to color their view of the many. I find it offensive either way.
Of course, if I lived in Texas, I might very well share your view...so there is that.
But you also seem to miss an important point. We are ALL called to ministry, of some sort. Whether that be the Altar Guild, or teaching Sunday School, or folding the parish newsletter. Whether people have poor social skills, are idiots, or have any number of other personality traits you find off-putting. God doesn't seem to exempt anyone from service just because they aren't as smart as you/we might like them to be.
That's the hard part about being in a community of faith---the idiots are called to minister along with the brilliant ones.
It is the ultimate irony that the idiots can be far more effective---if only in teaching people how NOT to be Christians---that those of us who consider ourselves "fit" for ministry.
Hey, Mark asked for my experiences. There they are. If you want me to have a different opinion, give me different data.
And I think the one guy was not an idiot, just annoying.
Lindy
If you want me to have a different opinion, give me different data.
Consider this a formal invitation for you and Rowan to visit Raleigh. My EFM group meets every Wednesday night from 7:00-9:30. :-)
Cheers,
Doxy
Post a Comment