Wednesday, September 26, 2007

S. O. B.

Standard Operational Bullshit

This is what we've gotten from the House of Bishops, and, like Fr. Jake, I was taken aback by the fury at what has been, pretty much, the status quo.

It actually gives me hope, but only if we can direct that anger. Here's what I wrote on Fr. Jake's site to another poster:

Well, to me, FS, it's not just a matter of good clergy, bad clergy in terms of spiritual qualities (humility, lack of restraint, et al) but what we seem to expect of them. We want businessmen good administrators. One of the very, very, very few things I respect about Reasserters is their emphasis on clergy's being called - though it is to a wrong and harmful vision, at least it's a vocation. We seem to be more concerned, in general, with having clergy who are well-spoken, diplomatic, a dab hand at the outgoing host, a good head for figures and fund-raising - in short, good businessmen - and little emphasis on their belief, their actual pastoral qualities (as opposed to merely being social), their empathy, their spiritual life -- I've heard the reports on spiritual development from seminarians referred to as "merely jumping through hoops!"

This may make for good business, but it makes for an abysmally mediocre episcopate. It's one of the reasons I actually oppose married clergy - particularly bishops - because ordination has to be more than a career choice.

I'm not speaking of the clergy I've known here, and I'm sorry if my words offend, and, especially, if they hurt, but I just think that we need to look differently at this HoB outcome.

I suppose, in essence, I agree with Jake that it's business as usual. But I find that sad and unacceptable - the "we're only human" line only stretches to the point that something has actually been attempted.

We should be regarding this, not as a slap in the face, but a rough shove into conscious awareness of the mediocrity that we've helped build into our leadership. We can simply be upset, or realize that we - the people of the church - are responsible for choosing our clergy, and from that clergy our bishops and that serious reform in that process has to happen.


The problem has been systemic.

Grandmere's bishop has seemed mostly to be a deer frozen in the headlights. My bishop has been resolute in ignoring any sort of problem in the church, whatsoever. Look at our diocesan website -- it's as if there was no Reasserter nonsense going on anywhere. I understand the need to put a good face on the inaction, the lack of clarity (usually masked by "We have to listen to the entire argument,") that our bishops have engaged in. I know my bishop, personally. Great guy. Great spiritual leader? Hell, no. It was painful to come to that realization, but it's true. There's no fire. Too much politician and too little guru. Unfortunately, I've heard the same under the defensiveness of certain other liberals as well.

The simple fact is, liberal or moderate, they simply were completely unprepared for anything like this. When it came down to it, they were playing "business as usual" and those they speak for were serious. That, I must say, the Reasserters have all over us. They actually are passionate about the beliefs, and the articulation of those beliefs, they represent. We are damned with lukewarm praise and tepid support from bishops who, though decent people, are completely unequipped for dealing with real theological controversy. They're great a homiletics, but it's all just regurgitating what they read in seminary. They think gay relationships are fine, but they have not really thought about it, and lack both the ability and conviction to clarify that position, and certainly lack the passion and fire to defend it in the teeth of "revilings, persecutions" etc. My priest is clear, theologically and socially, and concise on his defense of homosexual relationships with monogamy being the normative state. My bishop is clear on why we need to build more churches. He can't even explain what is the absolute good of the Anglican Communion.

I think that the opportunity here is to realize that we, and the priests and deacons, are gonna have to do this, leaving the dazed and worried bishops home to guard the silverware. When it's over, when can start real talks about reforming who and how we choose our clergy and our leadership from among them.

4 comments:

June Butler said...

Grandmere's bishop has seemed mostly to be a deer frozen in the headlights.

Mark, I do see movement in the right direction. He's not there yet, but one can hope.

This is the same man that I worried about taking the diocese out of the Episcopal Church a few short months ago.

I agree. The statement is sad.

janinsanfran said...

We had one of the businessman type bishops until recently. When our parish badly needed intervention, we had to nearly blow the guy out of the place to get some action. But he sure could raise a lot of money...

Now we seem to have a spiritual leader, at least I hope so. But like most Episcopalians, I think, mostly I don't look to my bishop for leadership -- too remote, too entitled.

MarkBrunson said...

Indeed.

We need something more than these career politicians, ambitious upper-management types. I think, though, it's going to have to be us that does it, even if the clergy wants to balk. We can't afford to keep letting a corporation masquerade as church.

fs said...

Sorry I didn't respond to your post at Jake's, Mark. Sometimes it's late and I'm tired and then new posts sprout up and it sort of moves along.

I do agree with you about the emphasis being on administration rather than religious leadership, and I'm coming to agreement on the issue of priest's being married -- or, some sort of sacrifice on their part that would make it more of a calling and less of a career choice. In our parish, the older priests have a quality of humble, giving, egolessness that is not evident in the newer ones. The latter seem to see themselves less as servants than superiors.

I'm curious how the discernment process works.

As for bishops, our recently retired bishop, though somewhat remote, always struck me as highly spiritual, but I can't tell yet with the new one. They are quite a bit removed from "the people." Those directly under him might have a better idea of his leadership qualities.