Thursday, August 16, 2007

I Still Say

It's time to officially divorce TEC from the Reasserters.

I hear the same arguments for "unity" and all the same, tired cries of limiting ourselves, screening out voices different from ours. I'm sorry, but I think that those are just people afraid of being called the bad guy. Sometimes, you have to have the courage to be the bad guy, and it's time to say goodbye - forcefully, if need be - to those who simply can no longer even feign respect for us, by inhibition, deposition, excommunication, whatever.

The simple fact is there is a great deal of diversity among liberals -- don't believe it? Try to find the "party line" on what's meant by a committed gay couple. See how I react about Redding's claims to two religions, as opposed to someone else. For that matter, look at the fact that many of us believe, as opposed to other liberals, that this tedious call for reconciliation is really rather silly, a sort of angelism -- it's been made clear from the Reasserter side that they will only accept capitulation.

On top of that, we are doing violence to ourselves as well as to the Reasserters. The damage they do to us is obvious, but we do a different sort of damage to them. Holding them in this perpetual tension of monologue-masquerading-as-dialogue, we give them a focus for the pervasive fear and hate that composes their "faith" -- take that away by cutting off our continued contact with them, and they will be forced back on themselves, and ultimately forced to confront a "faith" that's actually blinding them to their better parts. And, yes, I'll say the same for us, as there is a less obvious harm. We are decent people, trying - sometimes to the point of equivocation - to see the best in our enemies. Yet, even we are becoming churlish, hurtful, cruel - and that's harm to us. Their hate and irrational villification is poisoning our own discourse.

There may be, indeed, I expect there will be, reconciliation - but not in this generation.

5 comments:

klady said...

Well, if the blogosphere is any indication of the "mental health" condition of the parties, you may well be right.

I know you've taken this view for a long time. As the WWAC turns daily, in all its tedious agony, it just seems more and more an extrarordinary waste of energy, not to mention causing the harm you describe. Fortunately, in most solid TEC parishes, this has little impact on the parish level, but it's certainly got to affect bishops, dioceses, etc. as well as create ongoing bad press for all. Then there are the dissenters, thmeselves. I don't go to "those places" online often but I recall one woman recently at SF who actually complained (in passing) that all they talk about in her parish is the apostate TEC, in excruciating detail (precisely how and why *we* have gone astray). Who can take any pleasure or comfort in seeing them twist in this fashion waiting until the day they can have their own denomination? Yes, it makes us all sick.

I was thinking in reading some recent threads at Jake's (yes, one of which I included by 2 cents) how crazy it all was. Once upon a time such discussions of theology and church traditions might have been a positive endeavor, a means for people to share and gain spiritual insights. While some good things may be said, they inevitably get framed in the context of quarreling with trolls, a defensive posture instead of honest engagement and willingness to stretch one's mind and soul at the boundaries. It's very sad.

June Butler said...

Mark, I know how you must be pained by the rhetoric flying about, as I am, and I grant that my pain is not in the same category as yours, but I cannot agree with you about throwing them out.

If they are determined to go, then let them go. But I pray we will not make the exclusionary first step.

For those in authority, priests, bishops, who violate the canons of TEC, then consequences will follow. For those who try to take property that does not belong to them, there will be consequences.

Keeping in mind that despite Jesus' call to his followers to be one, we are riven by many divisions. I hope TEC does not make the first move to further division.

And then there is Jesus' call to love even those who do not love us, even our enemies.

For what it's worth.

MarkBrunson said...

I have to disagree, Mimi.

Putting someone out is not hate, and abandoning making a safe place for outcasts to make the privileged feel welcome is not love. We are simply refusing our responsibility.

If someone, no matter how close a relative, were in your home, abusing your other loved ones, wrecking the place, trying to turn your neighbors against you, you'd put them out simply because you know it's the best way to protect you and your loved ones.

Similarly, we're serving no one by claiming to be tolerant when we are simply allowing others to tear us apart and hold up what we claim to be important -- that is, if that claim is true and not, as Reasserters have stated, merely an attempt to be PC. Right now, I believe our leadership, including many that I love and respect, are mired in deep cowardice masquerading as a desire for Christian unity.

Suzer said...

I'm still not quite sure where I stand on this issue, but you make some excellent points, Mark. Thank you for sharing them. :)

June Butler said...

Mark, take courage. I have no power beyond the power of prayer. I'm not even much given to argue my points. Peace.