Saturday, July 28, 2007

In the Interest of Honesty

I keep hearing the reasserters repeating the same tired party-line and saying it's all in the interest of honest dialogue.

So, in the interest of the honesty reasserters claim to value, here ya go, guys:

Reasserters,

I don't trust you. I don't believe, for a second, that you mean anything but harm to me and mine. I don't believe that you lie, but simply that you cannot tell what truth is, and, if it's shown to you, will ignore it. I don't believe you can be dealt with in good faith, because it's not in you. I believe it is no longer helpful, and, for us reappraisers, has become actively harmful to us and ours to keep on dealing with you -- not just a "go your own way if you wish, reasserter brethren" but a "Time for you to go!" If I saw any of you "correcting" your reasserter brethren on their assumptions, stereotypes and name-calling as assiduously as you do us reappraisers, I might believe there was some point in continuing to try to dialogue with you, if you even said with any conviction that you might be wrong, if you made any attempt to refute the most vilely and clearly deceitful and hateful of you, I might be tempted to believe you at least mean well. You don't . You're family, but you're not my brothers -- no brother would do me the harm you have then lie about it, trying to pass it off as benefit -- and some family is toxic, and should only be met on neutral ground -- outside of your own home.

So, there's your honesty.

4 comments:

MadPriest said...

That's my view entirely, Mark. Not only is direct conversation with them a complete waste of time it also messes with your mind in a very damaging way. That, of course, is what they want.

Wormwood's Doxy said...

I have reluctantly come to the same conclusion, Mark. Ever since GC03, I have tried to engage in dialogue---tried to find some common ground that would keep us together.

But the bottom line is that their faith is fear-based. They believe God will zap you if you do the wrong thing or believe the wrong thing, so they don't dare change their minds. To do so would be to risk eternal damnation.

That is a sad and scary kind of "faith." That God is a brutal tyrant who sets humans up to fail. That God is not the God *I* worship---the God who, as he was dying on the cross, said "Father, forgive them..."

We worship different Gods. It is time for us to acknowledge that and move on.

June Butler said...

Mark, I agree that contending with them is useless and that it can be quite harmful. That's why I rarely visit certain web sites, and I never comment.

In my church, there are, I suppose, a few reasserters (perhaps, more than a few), but I don't hear from them. Family members are, indeed, sometimes toxic.

MarkBrunson said...

Thanks for comments, everyone!

Doxy, I wonder, increasingly, if they even really believe in God. Oh, I'm sure they believe they believe, but they seem to put an awful lot of emphasis on what they can accomplish. They seem to have very little faith that God acts, at all.