While I want to continue our discussions of the nature of a bishop, I also think there are some common threads coming out:
In short, I'm not the only one who believes a bishop is accountable; that episcopacy is something "done to" the laity.
Obviously, a bishop is more than mere administrator, upper management in the diocesan "branch office," just as priesthood is more than simply a "career choice." Obviously, there must be some recognition of a bishop's ability to govern and lead wisely, or we would simply have a congregational polity. To that end, there is a degree of submission and obedience expected from the laity, and rightly so. Among the many sound bites and cliches from the Reasserters, they have - inadvertantly, I imagine - given some truth; Truth is not decided by vote.
Among the many charges laid on a bishop, according to the BCP's ordination service, is the interpretation of the Gospel. This is important, I believe, because the word is not interpretation of "Scripture," but of "the Gospel" - the Good News. A bishop, in his/her leadership role, is to interpret what exactly the Good News is. This gives a great deal of authority to a bishop, but - and this is also very important - the same ordination holds the bishop in a remarkable position of accountability, not to institutional church, but to the sovereignty of Christ and the well-being of his/her people.
Some bishops - particularly "Windsor bishops" - have made a great deal of the role of the bishop in guarding the unity of "the Church," but this pales in comparison with the sheer number of times a bishop is mentioned as "chief priest," "fellow presbyter," to "follow Him who came, not to be served, but to serve, and to give His life as ransom for many." The bishop, while not required to take counsel with the laity, is required to "support all baptized people in their gifts and ministries, nourish them from the riches of God's grace . . .," to take counsel with his/her "fellow presbyters" - and we are all of the Royal Priesthood, by Grace. Finally, and most egregiously ignored by most of our bishops, is this:
"Will you boldly proclaim and interpret the Gospel of Christ, enlightening the minds and stirring up the conscience of your people?" (emphases mine)
This pastoral role - responsibility to actual people, to an actual lived-out gospel - is mentioned, enjoined, emphasized again and again, while the duty of "unity" is mentioned, as a charge, perhaps twice or three times, and not, then, to any sort of ecclesial structure, but to "The Church of God."
I may be wrong, and accept that I may be, but it seems to me that the great majority of bishops - ours, CofE's, Nigeria's, Uganda's, Sudan's, even beyond to RC and perhaps the various Orthodox bishops - are completely falling down in this, having traded their role as pastor and presbyter for that of management, operations executive. Perhaps the loss of pastorship(sic) in our episcopacy is the reason for our increasing irrelevance and lack of clear and attractive Spirit.
Please, give me your views.
Wednesday, July 30, 2008
Breakdown
I've been trying, during the remainder of the Lambeth Conference, to keep from any divining or critiquing, but I think, given the most recent presidential address by Archbishop Williams, we have to accept that, as long as Williams remains in Cantuar's seat, the AC is broken.
His comments in trying to "understand" the two sides demonstrate, on the liberal side, a complete disconnect with the actual beliefs and attempts and values of the liberal faction, and, on the conservative side, a complete disconnect with the realities of the manipulation, brutality, and deception of those in the leadership of the conservative faction.
The Archbishop of Canterbury, quite simply put, is so insulated from the people he is supposed to help guide and represent that he can no longer be taken to be "a part" of us.
While Williams, whose intellect has been woefully inadequate to the realities of his current office and whose quite obvious and destructive prejudice against America, represented by TEC, is in the archepiscopacy of Canterbury, there can be no reconciliation. Either America will be thrown out to make way for a volume business in Third World souls (and never mind the quality of the Christian), or TEC will be "allowed" to remain, without the possibility of ever having any trust in the Archbishop of Canterbury until Williams is out of the office.
He is, quite simply, untrustworthy. I believe that he - Williams - is also exceptionally power-hungry and selfish, as this grab for centralized power coming out of a Windsor Continuation Group entirely devoid of liberals demonstrates.
Unless there is a huge surprise coming out of Canterbury in the next few days, the only possible way TEC can survive is to withdraw all support, financial and otherwise, from the Anglican Communion - particularly Canterbury - until Williams has either accepted and publicly repented from his heavy-handed and uneven actions, or until he has been removed from office.
His comments in trying to "understand" the two sides demonstrate, on the liberal side, a complete disconnect with the actual beliefs and attempts and values of the liberal faction, and, on the conservative side, a complete disconnect with the realities of the manipulation, brutality, and deception of those in the leadership of the conservative faction.
The Archbishop of Canterbury, quite simply put, is so insulated from the people he is supposed to help guide and represent that he can no longer be taken to be "a part" of us.
While Williams, whose intellect has been woefully inadequate to the realities of his current office and whose quite obvious and destructive prejudice against America, represented by TEC, is in the archepiscopacy of Canterbury, there can be no reconciliation. Either America will be thrown out to make way for a volume business in Third World souls (and never mind the quality of the Christian), or TEC will be "allowed" to remain, without the possibility of ever having any trust in the Archbishop of Canterbury until Williams is out of the office.
He is, quite simply, untrustworthy. I believe that he - Williams - is also exceptionally power-hungry and selfish, as this grab for centralized power coming out of a Windsor Continuation Group entirely devoid of liberals demonstrates.
Unless there is a huge surprise coming out of Canterbury in the next few days, the only possible way TEC can survive is to withdraw all support, financial and otherwise, from the Anglican Communion - particularly Canterbury - until Williams has either accepted and publicly repented from his heavy-handed and uneven actions, or until he has been removed from office.
Tuesday, July 29, 2008
Apologies!
For those who've responded to my question about bishops -
THANK YOU, THANK YOU, THANK YOU!
I'm so sorry that I haven't had the chance to write, until now.
For those who don't know:
I only have computer access Mon-Fri nights, so I rarely, if ever, get the chance to even check the blog on the weekend, and, when I do have access, it is at work. Given that my employer is so kind, I take pains to make sure that I'm tending my job, first and foremost, which means that sitting down like this takes a bit of doing, and may not get done on busy nights.
I beg your patience.
What I'm trying to do, here, is establish what, in the mind of the TEC and the Church (by which I include all churches, congregational, RC, Anglican, Orthodox) and to see if, perhaps, we in TEC are missing something out here, or if we really are legitimately different, or, if perhaps others are missing something out.
A great deal of my concern is the accountability - reasonable accountability - of a bishop to the people, lay and clergy. I have been taken aback by the first Lambeth meeting I've ever followed, by the degree of secrecy surrounding the whole affair, and the forceful degree to which the non-bishops are being kept out -- it is unhealthy, to my thinking, and unholy. We are told by Our Lord that it is evil that is done under cover, so why must our bishops exclude us from their deliberations, even as informed observers? What reason is possibly so convincing for carrying out meetings that will affect our individual parishes in such seclusion and secrecy? Why should bishops be afraid to speak what they believe in front of the world? Isn't there something wrong, if they are unwilling to do so?
THANK YOU, THANK YOU, THANK YOU!
I'm so sorry that I haven't had the chance to write, until now.
For those who don't know:
I only have computer access Mon-Fri nights, so I rarely, if ever, get the chance to even check the blog on the weekend, and, when I do have access, it is at work. Given that my employer is so kind, I take pains to make sure that I'm tending my job, first and foremost, which means that sitting down like this takes a bit of doing, and may not get done on busy nights.
I beg your patience.
What I'm trying to do, here, is establish what, in the mind of the TEC and the Church (by which I include all churches, congregational, RC, Anglican, Orthodox) and to see if, perhaps, we in TEC are missing something out here, or if we really are legitimately different, or, if perhaps others are missing something out.
A great deal of my concern is the accountability - reasonable accountability - of a bishop to the people, lay and clergy. I have been taken aback by the first Lambeth meeting I've ever followed, by the degree of secrecy surrounding the whole affair, and the forceful degree to which the non-bishops are being kept out -- it is unhealthy, to my thinking, and unholy. We are told by Our Lord that it is evil that is done under cover, so why must our bishops exclude us from their deliberations, even as informed observers? What reason is possibly so convincing for carrying out meetings that will affect our individual parishes in such seclusion and secrecy? Why should bishops be afraid to speak what they believe in front of the world? Isn't there something wrong, if they are unwilling to do so?
Thursday, July 24, 2008
Question About Bishops
Trying to streamline and clarify what I asked yesterday.
SERIOUSLY. I WANT REPLIES. BRING FRIENDS, SINCE I TRY TO AVOID BLOG-WHORING.
COME FOR THE APE
Is it prideful for a "mere layman" to . . .request, or even demand, the information to process the situation and the bishop's response [rather than accepting the bishop's vague reassurances]?
Is it humility, or simple laziness, convenience, or fear that keep us from being more vocal in our opposition to bishops' actions, or, more frequently, inactions?
What is the place of the bishop?
Of the layman?
What are their roles respective to each other?
Is what I (we) have been doing simple bitching and whining, or, in all humility, do we have a right to be included in what our bishops are doing and discussing?
Thank you. I look forward to your answers.
SERIOUSLY. I WANT REPLIES. BRING FRIENDS, SINCE I TRY TO AVOID BLOG-WHORING.
COME FOR THE APE
STAY FOR THE INPUT!
The questions, excised and trimmed from yesterday's post:
Is it prideful for a "mere layman" to . . .request, or even demand, the information to process the situation and the bishop's response [rather than accepting the bishop's vague reassurances]?
Is it humility, or simple laziness, convenience, or fear that keep us from being more vocal in our opposition to bishops' actions, or, more frequently, inactions?
What is the place of the bishop?
Of the layman?
What are their roles respective to each other?
Is what I (we) have been doing simple bitching and whining, or, in all humility, do we have a right to be included in what our bishops are doing and discussing?
Thank you. I look forward to your answers.
Lambeth Roundup 7/23
My Lambeth Roundup tends to be the mere essentials of what I've lately heard.
Ready?
It was all pretty stupid and, when not bullying Americans or putting Americans down, or generally talking about how subhuman, un-Christian and basically nasty Americans are (and they smell, too), it was bible camp for people who shouldn't need it by now.
Deep theology continues. Send shovels, please.
I have looked at the utter garbage being spewed by a great many outside of TEC and the Americas, the lies and propaganda and the Archbishop of Canterbury-all-Americans! smiling about it and I wonder where our bishops' voices are, raised in protest. Well, there's +Leo from Southeast Florida who corrected some misconceptions and noted the disinformation on his blog and . . .
Well, no "and," really; that's it.
I've come to the conclusion that we're going to stay in the Anglican Communion, not because it's good or helpful, or any of that, but because we Americans like playing at ceremony and dress-up and any number of people will leave if we can't pretend to be a mini-RCC "with branch offices worldwide!" . . . even if it means we crush our consciences into a wall and throw them away.
Two things popped out at me.
First, Ivan Dias, Roman Catholic cardinal addressed the conference. He compared the AC to a Parkinson's sufferer. My response to this was:
Ready?
It was all pretty stupid and, when not bullying Americans or putting Americans down, or generally talking about how subhuman, un-Christian and basically nasty Americans are (and they smell, too), it was bible camp for people who shouldn't need it by now.
Deep theology continues. Send shovels, please.
I have looked at the utter garbage being spewed by a great many outside of TEC and the Americas, the lies and propaganda and the Archbishop of Canterbury-all-Americans! smiling about it and I wonder where our bishops' voices are, raised in protest. Well, there's +Leo from Southeast Florida who corrected some misconceptions and noted the disinformation on his blog and . . .
Well, no "and," really; that's it.
I've come to the conclusion that we're going to stay in the Anglican Communion, not because it's good or helpful, or any of that, but because we Americans like playing at ceremony and dress-up and any number of people will leave if we can't pretend to be a mini-RCC "with branch offices worldwide!" . . . even if it means we crush our consciences into a wall and throw them away.
Two things popped out at me.
First, Ivan Dias, Roman Catholic cardinal addressed the conference. He compared the AC to a Parkinson's sufferer. My response to this was:

For two reasons:
First - Parkinson's? Really, Cardster, ya wanna go there? Little tasteless, mebbe?
Second - Why is a cardinal of the Roman Catholic Church addressing our bishops about Anglican problems? Huh? In short:
Who hired Schmucky the Clown to come and entertain, and can we fire the person who did so (please let it be Rowan, please let it be Rowan!)?
Second:
Remember how Deng said we should immediately cease all actions against the schismatics?
Apparently, that doesn't apply to Deng's church, though. Details
Note who financed the operation, too.
Tuesday, July 22, 2008
Most of Us Have Read Deng's Outrageous Statements
If not here.
Again, I am trying to avoid anger and hatred, so, I give you, again, one of my favorite quotes, from one of my favorite Stoics, Marcus Aurelius:
"Say to yourself in the early morning: I shall meet today ungrateful, violent, treacherous, envious, uncharitable men. All of these things have come upon them through ignorance of real good and ill... I can neither be harmed by any of them, for no man will involve me in wrong, nor can I be angry with my kinsman or hate him; for we have come into the world to work together... "
Again, I am trying to avoid anger and hatred, so, I give you, again, one of my favorite quotes, from one of my favorite Stoics, Marcus Aurelius:
"Say to yourself in the early morning: I shall meet today ungrateful, violent, treacherous, envious, uncharitable men. All of these things have come upon them through ignorance of real good and ill... I can neither be harmed by any of them, for no man will involve me in wrong, nor can I be angry with my kinsman or hate him; for we have come into the world to work together... "
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
