After the comments by the Archfuckwit, I go to Thinking Anglicans, which is usually measured in its tone, thanks to Simon Sarmiento's moderation, even on brutally-divisive points.
I find this:
The Vatican has criticised this killing as well. Watching Americans, especially young people who were children at 9/11 dancing in the streets tells us how far things have fallen in the U.S. Or maybe their violent nature is just more open now. It looked like any jubilant crowd in Tehran. But then again, the U.S. has murdered its enemies before and wrapped itself in a cloak of righteousness. To them, they are the only people who mater on the planet, so, to paraphrase Nixon (with Frost), if the U.S. does it, it is not illegal.
Posted by: Richard Grand on Thursday, 5 May 2011 at 10:03pm BST
and this little charmer from someone who likes to claim his liberal guilt for all the rest of us 'Murkans:
Many people are saying this sort of thing, and I wonder how they cannot reflect that the U.S. has caused the deaths of thousands of unarmed innocent civilians in many parts of the world, most recently and notably in Iraq and Afghanistan. And what of the deaths of armed nationals whose offense is opposing foreign occupation of their native lands?
If we're uncomfortable with the cold-blooded killing of a man (and his staff) in his own home, I wonder that we're not more uncomfortable with the impersonal slaughter of wedding parties, motor convoys, and apartment house residents in the Middle East by missiles dropped from drone aircraft remotely controlled from centers in Nevada -- all to eliminate people suspected of organizing opposition to foreign occupation (ours). Sorry about the women and children in the area. No offense intended. Sign here for burial expenses.
The U.S. empire has operated outside public view in large part -- who knows about the conquest of the Philippines or the murder of the opposition party by our dictator in Peru? Nowadays, we can see how the beast operates, and it's not a pretty sight. But it undergirds the U.S. standard of living. Where to start unraveling it? The ABC, and the church at large, might give it some thought, instead of continuing to operate as a department of Empire, and apologist for the powers-that-be.
Posted by: Murdoch Matthew on Friday, 6 May 2011 at 5:09am BST
Now, I don't mind claiming my part of the guilt pie, but I am tired of the hypocrisy that claims that somehow Americans are the worst, most horrible, most dreadful creatures to ever have lived. Why we invented genocide and imperialism and war and murder! Whatever evil there is, we've done it more, worse, longer than any of the sainted nations of Europe! I have no problem with saying we are just as bad, but no worse. And Mr. Matthew's comment up there isn't an "I'm sorry we've done that" but "Look at how awful they are!"
Does nobody get this? That is the problem. "They" and "Us" - no matter how terrible "they" may be, "they" wouldn't be "them" without "us" being "us." Life doesn't happen in a vacuum.
Why is there a W.? Partially because of me. Why is there a Tea Party? Partially because of me. Why is there a Taliban? Partially because of me. Why was there an Osama bin Laden? Partially because of me. Why was there a sad, unedifying end to Osama bin Laden? Partially because of me.
And you, and everybody else.
And the hypocritical refusal to own that, the urge to point fingers is NOT cathartic, NOT a good way to relieve tension, NOT sound psychological practice, it is the whole goddamned reason the music keeps playing the exact same apocalyptic tune over and over.
If I fall into the trap of "What about what they did?!" - which I did! - I am playing the same sad, tired game.
Isolationism - that's the way to go. Maybe, if everybody, every person, was sent to their corners for a few decades, then they'd learn there are still problems with no "Them" to blame it on. Maybe a little isolation would teach us to honor one another and value the whole damned human community.
Friday, May 6, 2011
Wednesday, May 4, 2011
The Watchful Peace
That's a part of the Tolkien storytelling, too.
Sauron thrown down by the Last Alliance of Men and Elves, the Ring taken from him. The Watchful Peace, because he wasn't really gone.
When I started the Tolkien stuff last week, it was because I've been playing Battle for Middle Earth 2 and wanted to learn more about the places and folks involved. I was fascinated, so I shared it with the handful of folks who talk with me here. I didn't expect it to turn prophetic.
Osama bin Laden is dead. Huzzah! Rejoice! The Dark Lord is overthrown! Peace at last!
But the Ring remains.
I keep hearing people say how A Great Evil was removed from our world. Liberals and conservatives alike are pleased. Now, they say, we can get on with a good world.
But the Ring remains.
Bin Laden was a symptom. Just like the Tea Party, Palin, Whatsisname Ryan, the governors of Michigan and Wisconsin, Ghaddafi, the Syrian "Security Services," the Taliban. The evil embodied in these symptoms has absolutely not been removed - the lust for power, the crushing poverty and lack, or simply the avarice that perceives lack in plenty, all are still Right. There.
Worse, now we have the Ring!
A good, decent generous person wrote, without any irony, that there were still revolutionaries in the Middle East, still violence but "it's not aimed at the West," so bin Laden's death was the removal of a Great Evil. It's not hurting us, so it's okay. I felt sickened, though I know that isn't what she meant, it's what we mean, in our celebrating.
I keep being told that it wasn't revenge, but the execution of justice, and yet, when asked if the terrorist cells are gone now, I'm told they collapsed or became meaningless long ago.
Follow that? Bin Laden lost his power, because the cells collapsed, but we killed him to keep him from being a danger. And it's not, not, NOT! revenge. It's Justice.
Right here, a Tea Party movement has taken advantage of economic collapse to advance a pseudo-religious conservative totalitarianism that has gained, frankly, enormous ground and exposure. Yet, bin Laden was the source of terrorist religious totalitarianism, and we've removed him. This is what is being said.
The Ring survives, and is ours, now.
Power. Security. We don't have to worry about him, anymore. The rest of the world's on its own. We are strong, strong, STRONG! and have no fears. We are Good! THE Good! Others are poor, others are in filth and struggling, we are wealthy because we deserve it, because we are The Good, and the problems of others can't be helped. Those among us who aren't wealthy, we can ignore, because The Good killed The Bad and everyone will prosper because we, The Good, are powerful!
If we had brought him back, filthy, bedraggled, powerless and in handcuffs to stand trial helpless before the world, we, and they, would've known the Evil isn't gone. We would've kept fighting the really good fight, and destroyed our Ring. We made a dark idol, threw it down, and said we've ended Evil.
We've given ourselves a Watchful Peace, an illusion of triumph.
What I HOPE for this: with Osama gone, Barack Obama can get the nation focussed away from fear-mongering and war-talk, and get us back to building prosperity which will strengthen the world economy; we can begin forming talks with the Middle East with a stronger hand, which we will use only to get them to take us seriously, before seeing that we really can be allies; we can remove ourselves from Afghanistan and Iraq, and let them become the countries they wish to be and real partners with the U. S.; we can stop raising our children in fear and tension, and teach them love, trust and compassion again; Obama - hopefully having only been distracted for so long by this operation - can focus on cleansing the Tea stains from our people; sanity can return. We can use this Watchful Peace to actually destroy the subhuman Evil of separation and nationalism and capitalist greed that allowed a man to take the form of the Evil.
That's my HOPE.
Mom used to say, "Hope in one hand, shit in the other . . . see which fills up first."
Sauron thrown down by the Last Alliance of Men and Elves, the Ring taken from him. The Watchful Peace, because he wasn't really gone.
When I started the Tolkien stuff last week, it was because I've been playing Battle for Middle Earth 2 and wanted to learn more about the places and folks involved. I was fascinated, so I shared it with the handful of folks who talk with me here. I didn't expect it to turn prophetic.
Osama bin Laden is dead. Huzzah! Rejoice! The Dark Lord is overthrown! Peace at last!
But the Ring remains.
I keep hearing people say how A Great Evil was removed from our world. Liberals and conservatives alike are pleased. Now, they say, we can get on with a good world.
But the Ring remains.
Bin Laden was a symptom. Just like the Tea Party, Palin, Whatsisname Ryan, the governors of Michigan and Wisconsin, Ghaddafi, the Syrian "Security Services," the Taliban. The evil embodied in these symptoms has absolutely not been removed - the lust for power, the crushing poverty and lack, or simply the avarice that perceives lack in plenty, all are still Right. There.
Worse, now we have the Ring!
A good, decent generous person wrote, without any irony, that there were still revolutionaries in the Middle East, still violence but "it's not aimed at the West," so bin Laden's death was the removal of a Great Evil. It's not hurting us, so it's okay. I felt sickened, though I know that isn't what she meant, it's what we mean, in our celebrating.
I keep being told that it wasn't revenge, but the execution of justice, and yet, when asked if the terrorist cells are gone now, I'm told they collapsed or became meaningless long ago.
Follow that? Bin Laden lost his power, because the cells collapsed, but we killed him to keep him from being a danger. And it's not, not, NOT! revenge. It's Justice.
Right here, a Tea Party movement has taken advantage of economic collapse to advance a pseudo-religious conservative totalitarianism that has gained, frankly, enormous ground and exposure. Yet, bin Laden was the source of terrorist religious totalitarianism, and we've removed him. This is what is being said.
The Ring survives, and is ours, now.
Power. Security. We don't have to worry about him, anymore. The rest of the world's on its own. We are strong, strong, STRONG! and have no fears. We are Good! THE Good! Others are poor, others are in filth and struggling, we are wealthy because we deserve it, because we are The Good, and the problems of others can't be helped. Those among us who aren't wealthy, we can ignore, because The Good killed The Bad and everyone will prosper because we, The Good, are powerful!
If we had brought him back, filthy, bedraggled, powerless and in handcuffs to stand trial helpless before the world, we, and they, would've known the Evil isn't gone. We would've kept fighting the really good fight, and destroyed our Ring. We made a dark idol, threw it down, and said we've ended Evil.
We've given ourselves a Watchful Peace, an illusion of triumph.
What I HOPE for this: with Osama gone, Barack Obama can get the nation focussed away from fear-mongering and war-talk, and get us back to building prosperity which will strengthen the world economy; we can begin forming talks with the Middle East with a stronger hand, which we will use only to get them to take us seriously, before seeing that we really can be allies; we can remove ourselves from Afghanistan and Iraq, and let them become the countries they wish to be and real partners with the U. S.; we can stop raising our children in fear and tension, and teach them love, trust and compassion again; Obama - hopefully having only been distracted for so long by this operation - can focus on cleansing the Tea stains from our people; sanity can return. We can use this Watchful Peace to actually destroy the subhuman Evil of separation and nationalism and capitalist greed that allowed a man to take the form of the Evil.
That's my HOPE.
Mom used to say, "Hope in one hand, shit in the other . . . see which fills up first."
Tuesday, May 3, 2011
The Change
No. Not menopause.
The change in this blog.
I'm sorry, but I simply can't put everything out there for a certain sick cyber-stalker to harrass me over. I've just had enough of his vile, puerile and disgusting comments and his need to obsess over trying to convince me to take my own life. Since, apparently, no one in blogger gives a damn about respecting their bloggers, and Google is terribly concerned that allowing the freedom to block a commentator could cut down on their life-giving spam, until I can find a blog platform that does allow the ability to block specific commenters and can move the content of this blog there, I have made it private and will open it only to certain people.
If the blog becomes a total echo chamber, thank the one known as Nixon Is Lord for creating the situation. I simply won't be abused anymore, either by him or Blogger's lack of respect for the bloggers.
The change in this blog.
I'm sorry, but I simply can't put everything out there for a certain sick cyber-stalker to harrass me over. I've just had enough of his vile, puerile and disgusting comments and his need to obsess over trying to convince me to take my own life. Since, apparently, no one in blogger gives a damn about respecting their bloggers, and Google is terribly concerned that allowing the freedom to block a commentator could cut down on their life-giving spam, until I can find a blog platform that does allow the ability to block specific commenters and can move the content of this blog there, I have made it private and will open it only to certain people.
If the blog becomes a total echo chamber, thank the one known as Nixon Is Lord for creating the situation. I simply won't be abused anymore, either by him or Blogger's lack of respect for the bloggers.
Monday, May 2, 2011
So, They Killed Bin Laden
Aside from being able to sneer at Republican'ts because Bush wasn't able to do it, it really doesn't accomplish much.
You want to preserve peace and democracy? Send Navy Seals to kill Sarah Palin and anyone who belongs to the Tea Party and/or is among the richest 1% of the U. S. population.
You want to preserve peace and democracy? Send Navy Seals to kill Sarah Palin and anyone who belongs to the Tea Party and/or is among the richest 1% of the U. S. population.
Wednesday, April 27, 2011
The Temple of Morgoth
Tolkien's Akallabeth, which tells the story of the fall of Numenor, talks about the corruption brought by Sauron.
Synopsis time: Sauron's sort of a spirit being, of lower order than the Ainur, who were created by the One Creator, Eru. Morgoth was an Ainu who wanted all Creation to mirror his vision, and, when Eru said that wasn't possible, got angry and decided to wreck up the joint. At that time, he was called Melko or Melkor and he recruited several Maiar (lower order beings) including one named Mairon. Melkor became called "Morgoth" - Dark Enemy - and Mairon, his Lieutenant, became known as "Gorthaur" - The Cruel (NOTE: I've been told this actually means "Much Feared" and "the Cruel" is an epithet) - and, later, "Sauron" - The Abhorred. Morgoth corrupted early humans by convincing them that the voice of Eru and the Ainur who came to the created world (called the Valar), was the voice of consuming Darkness and worshipping him, Morgoth, would save them. This brought death. Familiar enough story.
Some men resisted, but still were tainted by Morgoth's corruption. They helped drive Morgoth out into the Void, and beat back Sauron et al. They were given a special land called Numenor. The world was flat, at that time, and stretched out straight to the land of the Valar - Valinor - in the West. Numenor lay between Middle Earth and Valinor, but the Numenoreans were forbidden to sail farther West than they could see their shore. Sauron - at first claiming to be a Valar representative named Annatar, "Lord of Gifts" - rose in Middle Earth, made his own dark empire based in Mordor with the help of the Ring, and began declaring himself Lord of Men. He remained loyal to Morgoth, and instituted the worship of Morgoth as a way to corrupt creation so far that Morgoth would be able to come back from the Void.
Meantime, the men of Numenor - who've never seen the Valar and resent the "gift" of mortality - begin a-grumbling. Some - the Faithful - remain loyal to the Valar, while others - the King's Men - say that only Man has a right to decide his destiny. After a while, the kings of Numenor become prouder and more determined to escape death. It's important to realize that mortality is a gift in Tolkien's lore; the Elves fade and become bored with their lives in the created universe, and seek to leave eventually and go to Valinor and a non-corporeal existence. Finally, Ar-Pharazon, last of the kings of Numenor, goes with a massive army to Middle Earth and humbles Sauron - then brings him back to Numenor as a hostage. Sauron, obviously, begins to play to Pharazon's weakness for power and immortality, rapidly becomes chief advisor, institutes Morgoth worship and the great temple with himself as the chief priest, where the Faithful and "lesser" men from Middle Earth are burned as sacrifices to gain Morgoth's favor and the gift of immortality. He convinces men that Eru is a lie the Valar told to keep men from gaining their freedom - so, ironically, Morgoth becomes known as the God of Freedom. Finally, Sauron convinces Pharazon to invade Valinor. As Pharazon sets foot on Valinor, Eru "bends" the world, making it a sphere, cutting it off from Valinor, Pharazon and his army are buried in the Caves of the Forgotten, and Numenor sinks. Sauron's form is destroyed, and he flees to Middle Earth, where he is unable to assume a pleasing form again. Some men escape - Elendil, Isildur, and Anarion and their Faithful group - and come to Middle Earth. That's where the Lord of the Rings picks up, Aragorn being descended from Elendil's son, Isildur.
Here's an artist's depiction of the capital city of Armenelos, with the great temple belching out its continual sacrificial offerings.
So, to avoid death, to gain prosperity, the Numenoreans threw their minority and the "lesser men" onto the fires. No grander evil than the common, grubby desire for security, wealth and long life no matter what expense to others.
Hmm. Anything familiar?
Synopsis time: Sauron's sort of a spirit being, of lower order than the Ainur, who were created by the One Creator, Eru. Morgoth was an Ainu who wanted all Creation to mirror his vision, and, when Eru said that wasn't possible, got angry and decided to wreck up the joint. At that time, he was called Melko or Melkor and he recruited several Maiar (lower order beings) including one named Mairon. Melkor became called "Morgoth" - Dark Enemy - and Mairon, his Lieutenant, became known as "Gorthaur" - The Cruel (NOTE: I've been told this actually means "Much Feared" and "the Cruel" is an epithet) - and, later, "Sauron" - The Abhorred. Morgoth corrupted early humans by convincing them that the voice of Eru and the Ainur who came to the created world (called the Valar), was the voice of consuming Darkness and worshipping him, Morgoth, would save them. This brought death. Familiar enough story.
Some men resisted, but still were tainted by Morgoth's corruption. They helped drive Morgoth out into the Void, and beat back Sauron et al. They were given a special land called Numenor. The world was flat, at that time, and stretched out straight to the land of the Valar - Valinor - in the West. Numenor lay between Middle Earth and Valinor, but the Numenoreans were forbidden to sail farther West than they could see their shore. Sauron - at first claiming to be a Valar representative named Annatar, "Lord of Gifts" - rose in Middle Earth, made his own dark empire based in Mordor with the help of the Ring, and began declaring himself Lord of Men. He remained loyal to Morgoth, and instituted the worship of Morgoth as a way to corrupt creation so far that Morgoth would be able to come back from the Void.
Annatar (Sauron's disguise)
Meantime, the men of Numenor - who've never seen the Valar and resent the "gift" of mortality - begin a-grumbling. Some - the Faithful - remain loyal to the Valar, while others - the King's Men - say that only Man has a right to decide his destiny. After a while, the kings of Numenor become prouder and more determined to escape death. It's important to realize that mortality is a gift in Tolkien's lore; the Elves fade and become bored with their lives in the created universe, and seek to leave eventually and go to Valinor and a non-corporeal existence. Finally, Ar-Pharazon, last of the kings of Numenor, goes with a massive army to Middle Earth and humbles Sauron - then brings him back to Numenor as a hostage. Sauron, obviously, begins to play to Pharazon's weakness for power and immortality, rapidly becomes chief advisor, institutes Morgoth worship and the great temple with himself as the chief priest, where the Faithful and "lesser" men from Middle Earth are burned as sacrifices to gain Morgoth's favor and the gift of immortality. He convinces men that Eru is a lie the Valar told to keep men from gaining their freedom - so, ironically, Morgoth becomes known as the God of Freedom. Finally, Sauron convinces Pharazon to invade Valinor. As Pharazon sets foot on Valinor, Eru "bends" the world, making it a sphere, cutting it off from Valinor, Pharazon and his army are buried in the Caves of the Forgotten, and Numenor sinks. Sauron's form is destroyed, and he flees to Middle Earth, where he is unable to assume a pleasing form again. Some men escape - Elendil, Isildur, and Anarion and their Faithful group - and come to Middle Earth. That's where the Lord of the Rings picks up, Aragorn being descended from Elendil's son, Isildur.
Here's an artist's depiction of the capital city of Armenelos, with the great temple belching out its continual sacrificial offerings.
So, to avoid death, to gain prosperity, the Numenoreans threw their minority and the "lesser men" onto the fires. No grander evil than the common, grubby desire for security, wealth and long life no matter what expense to others.
Hmm. Anything familiar?
Tuesday, April 26, 2011
Religion in Tolkien
I've always considered it odd that JRR Tolkien - himself so devout a Roman Catholic as to refuse to abandon Latin responses in the Mass - created Middle Earth as a place of great spirituality, reverence, holiness, full of the power of Divinity, but, largely, religionless. It's not a thing I find unpleasant, but unexpected. The only mentions of an actual religion - organized religion, as opposed to active devotion to and service of Eru and the Valar - is Sauron's imposition of the state religion of Morgoth-worship and human sacrifice.
Perhaps, even an old die-hard RC knew, somewhere, that long ago the question of authority and discernment, so important to the early Christians, was a lever for lesser men to seize power and take authority upon themselves to the exclusion of the Body. It has been so so long that there may be no saving the religion.
As a side-note; if you ever wondered what a temple to Morgoth would look like, Tolkien said that the Radcliffe Camera looked like it:
Perhaps, even an old die-hard RC knew, somewhere, that long ago the question of authority and discernment, so important to the early Christians, was a lever for lesser men to seize power and take authority upon themselves to the exclusion of the Body. It has been so so long that there may be no saving the religion.
As a side-note; if you ever wondered what a temple to Morgoth would look like, Tolkien said that the Radcliffe Camera looked like it:
Monday, April 25, 2011
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



