Don't misunderstand, there have been some decentish versions, but none got it quite right - this is discounting the excresence produced in the 1990's with Tim Curry and Kiefer Sutherland, both of whom should've known better.
Charlton Heston's Richelieu was decrepit. De Winter of the 30's and 40's too wholesome. Michael York - whom I like - was far too imposing as D'Artagnan . . . he looked like a young man who kid kick your butt.
So, we have another in 2011, and here's how things look-
Logan Lerman's D'Artagnan has swagger, but looks like a grungy, scrawny farm kid. He'd be the sort underestimated by the sophisticates and old veterans.
Comte de Rochefort is one of my favorites, and I love Mads Mikkelson's bad guys. His Rochefort, while less polished-looking, he radiates a hawklike, contemptuous hauteur.
The Musketeers themselves. Old enough to be a bit jaded, but not so old you couldn't believe they'd be up for a bit of swashbuckling.
Milla Jovovich looks a promising Lady DeWinter - reminds me of a younger Famke Janssen. Orlando Bloom is Buckingham on the right, but Buckingham's kind of hard to get wrong.
Christoff (sic) Waltz (best known to USA from Inglorious Basterds), as Armand-Jean du Plessis, Duc de Richelieu and Chief Advisor to the King. I like that he is a man of vigorous middle years, neither doddering, like Heston's Cardinal Richelieu, nor entirely cerebral, like Vincent Price's Richelieu. His armor seems modeled from the painting of him at La Rochelle, a good reminder that he was a soldier, as well as a nobleman and Cardinal.
There is one thing that fills me with dread about this film, so far - two little symbols . . .
3-D.










