Tuesday, December 8, 2009

Carol History


It's well-known that some of the greatest classic carols come from historical events.


It just is, trust me.


Few people know of the historical basis of one of the most enduring Christmas favorites.


The carol's history began in the 1400's during the Yuletide raisin famine of East Westchester. The peasants, desperate to make their puddings, marched on the Earl of Sweetenlough's castle. It was a shaky start, but the Earl explained, quite kindly under the circumstances, that it was, in fact, the Earl of East Wheedling, some thirty miles back in the direction they came, who was their liege-lord. He gave them some biscuits and mulled wine and pointed them in the right direction. The resolute, but woefully inaccurate, mob continued to stop to demand raisins at any suitably-large farmhouse or - frequently - tavern to demand their rights and their dried fruit.


At each house, they were re-oriented, given something to eat and drink, and sent - kindly, as with a confused elderly person - on their way. The result was that, by the time East Wheedling, with its towering raisin silos and groaning sultana-lofts, was reached, the starving peasants had gained several pounds and had to frequently stop to combat bouts of indigestion.


Still, it was resolutely that the mob faced the forebidding walls of the Earl's castle. Here, we are reminded of their cry, somewhat altered by poetic license:


Oh, bring us some figgy pudding!

Oh, bring us some figgy pudding!

Oh, bring us some figgy pudding!

And bring it out here!


The earl himself was, unfortunately, in London for the holiday, but, seeing how far they'd come and how game they were for a revolt, the captain of the guard (and chief gardener) offered them a cry in cheerful recognition of the crowd's bravery, though it is neglected in the official history:


"Oi! Bugger off you filthy, drunken lot!"


This was exactly the wrong thing to say to a group determined, incensed, emboldened, and, above all, filthy and drunk. The crowd pressed forward. The inexperienced men-at-arms panicked. It was the perfect storm of historicity, bringing together stupidity and ignorance.


At 10:21 pm, the captain ordered the pudding catapults loaded.


At 10:38 pm, the crowd surging once again, the captain ordered the puddings flamed.


At 10:39 pm, the catapults were fired, raining sugary, doughy, brandied hell onto the raisin revolters. Casualties were numerous, limbs and eyes accounted for by hard-sauce shrapnel as much as by the brandy-fueled fires colliding with the ale-fueled peasants. Still, the peasants stood their ground through the night. Once again, song commemorates, devoid of all swearwords and screams for buckets of water, the protesters' words:


We won't leave until we've had some!

We won't leave until we've had some!

We won't leave until we've had some!

So, bring it out here!


The revolting peasants - doused and soused as they were - stood their ground all night until morning, when they gave up and left, the guard having nipped out back down to the pub.


So, whenever you sing "We Wish You a Merry Christmas," remember the brave, and largely pointless, sacrifice of these few, these proud, these . . . people over here who called for raisins.

This is a photograph, obviously not from the 1400's, and has nothing to do with this story. It's Alaskan oil fires, or something.

The Archbastard of Canterbury

I was going to blog on his pompous bull (that's for sure) about the LA episcopal election, but, you know what? I feel pretty good right now, considering yesterday: you see, we don't have a choir director, but a young, overburdened tenor who is doing his best, but is not our official choir director, and only took on the interim because there was no one else willing to do it. As a result, we attempted parts on a last-minute change in the setting for the Canticle of Zechariah, with the result that, even in unison on harmony, we were embarrassingly awful. We have a musical presentation announced for Christmas Eve, and almost no practice time between now and then.

So, to hell with Rowan Williams.

If you don't know about his veiled threats, attempting to strong-arm TEC, then here you go.

The discussion at Thinking Anglicans has been pretty indicative of general reaction.

All I'll post is a picture from Susan Russell's blog, which best sums up the archbishop's archfailure.

Saturday, December 5, 2009

Cultural Christian

I had run into the expression "Cultural Jew" and found it fascinating.

Basically put, and with the caveat of it being my understanding in this paraphrase, cultural Judaism operates from a default of Judaic law and commentary, but with the active application of ongoing intellectual and spiritual understanding on a personal level.

Now, if I'm presenting a concept that's already been presented, I put it down to a wanting education, but, I think the concept of a cultural Christian might apply to me. I start from the default of Scripture and Tradition, but those cannot be overarching concerns, they are not the final arbiter. The reason for this is simple: I believe what Jesus promised. Now, for most people, it seems all that is remembered is the promise of some Apocalyptic return, but the most important promise to me, is that each of us would be sent the Advocate, the Spirit, whatever you call it, to guide us. This clearly indicates that we were expected to exercise a discernment far more important than "check the book then check with grandpa." That, to me, is far more trivial and ridiculous than any serious engagement that questions the (pre)suppositions of archaic formularies. How, I would ask, can God live, if the living God in us isn't that God? I'm not avoiding the concept of egoic self-will and evil - I've written a lot on them on mine and others' blogs - but God lives into a changing and evolving universe and is part of that as well as transcending it, and we are a part of Him, and He a part of us. God is immanent, as well as transcendant, so He must express Himself within the changes of understanding and environment, as well. Without that, we can say, quite clearly, the Incarnation had no meaning! Without meaning to the Incarnation, without a participatory God, the Resurrection means nothing. Our faith had been in vain.

The exercise of this cultural Christianity does not happen in isolation. I reject or accept things for myself, it's true, but I also am conscious of the community. If it were simply my conviction that homosexuality is not inherently disordered (and the inherent is an important part), then I would limit that belief to me. But, I have found this belief to have far wider expression, and to have far greater objective backing than that which I had found. I've spoken on my problems with WO, but I found myself re-evaluating in community, and, finally, personally, as well. As a Christian, I must accept that a wrong-doing against me is a minor thing, and can act or not act as I see fit, but wrong-doing against a group, even a smallish group of which I am a part, calls for me, as a Christian, to exercise whatever abilities I have to establish justice. The trope is "there is no such thing as a Christian in isolation" but there is no such thing as Christianity in isolation, as well. We are not a tribe, or a chosen people but a force in the entirety of humanity, working for all humanity's salvation. We've constantly interfered, but rarely participated in that salvation. We seem to be willing to limit "help" to Christians. To me, this is bizarre, and I can no more accept that Christian charity, compassion and goodwill is limited to Christians than I can accept that those people arguing that limitation as valid are truly Christian! It's impossible. It's outside of possibility, or, again, Jesus came for absolutely nothing.

That is why I believe that there can be no final appeal to Scripture and Tradition - these are dead things, dead because they stand apart. In the absence of harm, and certainly in the evidence of their giving comfort and stability, they are to be embraced, but their suppositions and position must never be given sacrosanct quality, or we strip God of the humanity He endured so much to achieve.

Friday, December 4, 2009

Diary - 12/4/09

Day 4 of the relentless assault from the speakers in our lobby.


It's remarkable how few Christmas songs there really are, and how many recordings there are of those few, and, of all those recordings, how there are only one or two orchestrations in all the vast mathematical variety of musical notation. Astounding.


That, and how many of the Christmas songs are sung by Jewish singers. Maybe that's why I feel the call of Jewish traditions in Advent. Maybe I'll record a Hanukkah album.


By far, the most painful is the brick-minded insistence that the most famous recording of a song is the only recording anyone wants to hear.


Bing Crosby is now my nemesis.


I can't really blame him, of course. I'm certain he never meant for Christmas in Killarney to be played every five minutes, sometimes, seemingly, interrupting other songs just to assault my ears with the bullshit fantasy of an Irish jig being played by full orchestra. It makes me want to spend the next holiday season in Killarney. I bet they never play that crap there. I bet they get drunk and beat the hell out of anyone that mentions Bing Crosby. I want to come home, and scream at the top of my lungs, every time I hear that ghastly brass section wheezing it's cheerful little leprechaun-fart tune, "Actually, I've been, and what they do for Christmas in Killarney is get pissed, fight and fuck!!!!" That, I'm often assured, is a true Irish Christmas. It's a true American Christmas, too, for that matter. Burn in hell, Currier and Ives, on a fire of composted Claxton fruitcakes.


That's why, this weekend, I remember that special person, whose special day is - thought not the Reason for the Season (and I'll personally take an axe handle to whoever came up with that phrase, too) - embodies it's true spirit:


THE KRAMPUS

Thursday, December 3, 2009

IT'S NOT CHRISTMAS, YET, DAMMIT!

Okay, so this is not a movie about Hanukkah, either, but it looks funny and has a bit of eye-candy for every taste (personally, I find all three sons, Max Greenfield - sans beard - Ben Feldman, and the adorable Adam Lamberg all scrumptious).




Strangely, Advent makes me think, not of all the Christian traditions and the Anglo-German accretions onto the Christmas season (except for Krampusnacht, Dec. 5th!) onto the Christmas season, but, rather, Jewish tradition and custom. Odd, I suppose, as at one time my referring to Greenfield, Feldman and Lamberg as "scrumptious" would've gotten me stoned to death - and still would, in some parts of the Jewish world.

For whatever reason - a childhood in Miami, a strangely-urbane mother, a natural tendency to go against the flow - it's the Jewish tradition I feel drawn to in Advent. One moment of subtle cosmic harmony came today as I watched a documentary - very short - on the pogroms and clearing of the shtetls, followed by a collection of photos found amongst the confiscated possessions from the inmates after the liberation of Auschwitz. I felt, with each photo, a "sword pierce my soul."

Tuesday, December 1, 2009

A Salute To Katharine Jefferts-Schori and Rowan Williams

I BELIEVE IT'S IMPORTANT THAT WE ACKNOWLEDGE ALL THAT THEY'VE DONE FOR GAYS AND HIV-SUFFERERS IN AFRICA!


Sunday's Advent(ure)

Fr. Jay isn't afraid to shake things up, I grant you.

His regular update emails (and that's a change in itself) had these two bits in it:

I have made one noticeable change at St. Patrick's for the season in order to emphasize this time of watching for Christ... wherever we may find him. We have moved the altar against the wall for the next four weeks. For some of you, this will remind you of the churches where you grew up. For others, you will notice the immediate difference that I won't face you while celebrating the Eucharist. This will seem strange and jarring to many... and that is exactly my hope!

But wait! There's more!

For Advent, I have also made two changes to our liturgy. First, we will use an authorized form of Rite I, translated into contemporary language. While it does not include the "thee's" and "thou's" of Rite I, it does preserve some of the beautiful imagery of the liturgy from that time right after the Reformation. Second, we will include what is called, "the Last Gospel." For centuries, the Tridentine Mass included the prologue to John's gospel (In the beginning was the Word...) as the final pronouncement of the Eucharist liturgy. As we emphasize our watching and waiting for the Word to become flesh, we will end each service with this pronouncement again.

So, we got the odd oriental thing going on, as well as a different liturgical cadence.

Two things I noticed: First, I wasn't particularly put off by the priest's facing east. It didn't make a jarringly different experience, except that his voice became a bit muffled at times. I did notice that those in the congregation facing forward - our choir is seated to the side - would have difficulty seeing the actions performed, and, at certain points, the prayers would be harder to hear. I think that it's part of the old "smoke and mirrors" approach to the mystery of the Eucharist promulgated by antiquated Catholicism; instead of having a laity educated enough to understood the theology and symbolism, you substitute fake "mystery" in the guise of "What's he doing up there making all those weird movements?" "What's that that he's mumbling? Is it some kind of sacred secret words?" Other than that, the idea of symbolism in "facing the same way" never occurred to me, because God doesn't live to the east of us - we were all always facing the same way, even when facing each other. So, neither a plus or a minus on the ad orientem, just a novelty, from my perspective.

Second, the constant repetition and self-reproach in the Rite I liturgy. Now, if this were to be our liturgy all the time, I would protest. The constant, almost masochistic repetition of "We're so awful, You can't possibly really love us, and we're lucky just to be ground under Your Divine Heel, but maybe, if it's not to much trouble, you could . . . " would be bad theological practice. God created us, so there is original goodness as well as what might be called original sin; the entire universe and all its components - which atheists can appreciate, as well - conspired to created exactly one you, so you're pretty important. Still, in a season of reflection, it's good to see the sparks of rebellion, even anger, in expecting me to humble myself as "unworthy." The fact is, though, we are unworthy, even in the face of that original goodness and cosmic importance; we constantly cling to our egoistic selves, cutting great swathes of destruction through other, equally good and cosmically-important lives. We misuse our will, our reason - and often misuse both in service to religion, rather than God and Truth (witness the RCC hierarchy and conservative protestantism) - and create havoc, quite willingly. So, change in liturgy, a seasonal A+. The liturgy should teach and provoke to thought, not "just be there."