Wednesday, September 16, 2009
Sunday, September 13, 2009
Hurrah! Is Surviving for Everyone!
We have a new bishop here in the Diocese of Georgia.
Scott Benhase, rector of St. Alban's in D. C., has been elected as the tenth bishop of Georgia.
All his election-committee "stuff" is HERE.
Scott Benhase, rector of St. Alban's in D. C., has been elected as the tenth bishop of Georgia.
All his election-committee "stuff" is HERE.
Thursday, September 10, 2009
Wednesday, September 9, 2009
September 9th
James has sent in a couple of excellent articles to illustrate the importance and depth of the health-care crisis:
From Austin, TX, hotbed of liberal journalism.
and
From CNN, socialist/communist mouthpiece of the nation.
As regards the ongoing battles in the AC, which are as pointless and unnecessary as always, comes a bit of sanity from Frank Turner:
The Imagined Community of the Anglican Communion.
Note, it always seems to be clergy, in particular bishops, banging the "importance-of-the-Anglican-Communion" drum - maybe it's time to do what just about no other national church can do and clip the hell out of our bishops' wings. It's clear this is about personal interest, and bishops are just as susceptible to lobbying and toadyism as any other politician - take away that ability, and see how important they thing the AC really is.
On a more personal note:
I've realized, thanks to the contributions of a priest I've believed dedicated and rational and the actions of our clergy - particularly bishops - that, all this time, I've been fighting for a church that doesn't want to change, wants all its privileges and no risk and is, far from being a refuge for those who look for rationality and flexibility in religion, merely a refuge for the remainder of the Love Generation and the tail-end of yuppie "sensitivity" who'll scream from the rooftops for justice and love and righteousness for someone half a world away, a different color or different belief, and simply ignore the suffering of their neighbors, step over the bodies of those like them without so much as a backward glance. A friend of mine, James in fact - far from a conservative - has said to me, "Liberals are assholes." I've begun to think he's right.
You see, on a level, the orthodites are right: the Episcopal Church doesn't believe in what it's fighting for, or we would've thrown this Covenant back in Williams' face and told him, in so many words, to keep his hairy ass in his own church. We would've actually sent people - not money - in to help in Nigeria and Uganda, and without the damned politicking to make sure we don't step on purple toes. We would've said, loudly and clearly, that Akinola is a combination of voodoo witch-doctor and tribal war-chief and nothing like a bishop, without biting nails over the reaction of Canterbury.
The Episcopal Church does not believe in anything it's doing, and it's not just the bishops - as awful as they are.
Our clergy and lay-people will throw money and words to anything for justice - as long as it's fashionable and costs nothing more than that. As long as it doesn't hurt our PR. As long as we can be the "good guys," the "nice guys." You know, for all their wickedness, it doesn't shock me to hear from the Roman Catholics, or Baptists that one of theirs was killed or captured working in a dangerous area, for making the wrong noises before a dictator, but it would be a shock, an impossibility that you'd ever hear that of an Episcopalian. Episcopalians don't actually believe in anything, but what's fashionable and easy.
The refuge of the Love Generation and the remnants of socially-conscious yuppies.
And, it's just about put a stake through the heart of my belief in any damned thing, anymore. I've got more damned stress than most could handle just being me - our company cutting employees, hours, pay, clinical depression, health and housing problems - and, on top of that, to realize that Christianity is divided into those who believe and fight for wickedness and destruction, and those who believe in nothing costly at all and invest themselves in nothing at all. What God relies on that for His work? What good is that God? Could such a God exist, or, if He does, why should I worry whether someone so ineffectual disapproves of my actions?
These questions - particularly of the actual existence of God - are not ones I'm used to asking. I know God exists, because I feel Him, just like I can feel the presence of other people in my town without seeing them. So, I'm going to stay at St. Pat's, in the choir if they want, and keep on until this Covenant is voted in by GC, which it will be, and we no longer are even the weak-as-water Episcopalians we were, but some unrecognizable mini-Rome. Then, I'll leave, and see whether or not I still feel God at all. In the meantime, I can't keep fighting and involving myself in a church that, vampire-like, feeds off my energy and gives nothing back.
It's all up to you, if you feel the fight's worth it. I got no more investment. I can't, if I want to survive.
ADDENDUM:
And, now, something completely unrelated, because I give up and silly and cute is better than all the noise:
From Austin, TX, hotbed of liberal journalism.
and
From CNN, socialist/communist mouthpiece of the nation.
As regards the ongoing battles in the AC, which are as pointless and unnecessary as always, comes a bit of sanity from Frank Turner:
The Imagined Community of the Anglican Communion.
Note, it always seems to be clergy, in particular bishops, banging the "importance-of-the-Anglican-Communion" drum - maybe it's time to do what just about no other national church can do and clip the hell out of our bishops' wings. It's clear this is about personal interest, and bishops are just as susceptible to lobbying and toadyism as any other politician - take away that ability, and see how important they thing the AC really is.
On a more personal note:
I've realized, thanks to the contributions of a priest I've believed dedicated and rational and the actions of our clergy - particularly bishops - that, all this time, I've been fighting for a church that doesn't want to change, wants all its privileges and no risk and is, far from being a refuge for those who look for rationality and flexibility in religion, merely a refuge for the remainder of the Love Generation and the tail-end of yuppie "sensitivity" who'll scream from the rooftops for justice and love and righteousness for someone half a world away, a different color or different belief, and simply ignore the suffering of their neighbors, step over the bodies of those like them without so much as a backward glance. A friend of mine, James in fact - far from a conservative - has said to me, "Liberals are assholes." I've begun to think he's right.
You see, on a level, the orthodites are right: the Episcopal Church doesn't believe in what it's fighting for, or we would've thrown this Covenant back in Williams' face and told him, in so many words, to keep his hairy ass in his own church. We would've actually sent people - not money - in to help in Nigeria and Uganda, and without the damned politicking to make sure we don't step on purple toes. We would've said, loudly and clearly, that Akinola is a combination of voodoo witch-doctor and tribal war-chief and nothing like a bishop, without biting nails over the reaction of Canterbury.
The Episcopal Church does not believe in anything it's doing, and it's not just the bishops - as awful as they are.
Our clergy and lay-people will throw money and words to anything for justice - as long as it's fashionable and costs nothing more than that. As long as it doesn't hurt our PR. As long as we can be the "good guys," the "nice guys." You know, for all their wickedness, it doesn't shock me to hear from the Roman Catholics, or Baptists that one of theirs was killed or captured working in a dangerous area, for making the wrong noises before a dictator, but it would be a shock, an impossibility that you'd ever hear that of an Episcopalian. Episcopalians don't actually believe in anything, but what's fashionable and easy.
The refuge of the Love Generation and the remnants of socially-conscious yuppies.
And, it's just about put a stake through the heart of my belief in any damned thing, anymore. I've got more damned stress than most could handle just being me - our company cutting employees, hours, pay, clinical depression, health and housing problems - and, on top of that, to realize that Christianity is divided into those who believe and fight for wickedness and destruction, and those who believe in nothing costly at all and invest themselves in nothing at all. What God relies on that for His work? What good is that God? Could such a God exist, or, if He does, why should I worry whether someone so ineffectual disapproves of my actions?
These questions - particularly of the actual existence of God - are not ones I'm used to asking. I know God exists, because I feel Him, just like I can feel the presence of other people in my town without seeing them. So, I'm going to stay at St. Pat's, in the choir if they want, and keep on until this Covenant is voted in by GC, which it will be, and we no longer are even the weak-as-water Episcopalians we were, but some unrecognizable mini-Rome. Then, I'll leave, and see whether or not I still feel God at all. In the meantime, I can't keep fighting and involving myself in a church that, vampire-like, feeds off my energy and gives nothing back.
It's all up to you, if you feel the fight's worth it. I got no more investment. I can't, if I want to survive.
ADDENDUM:
Doxy rightly called me on my use of "Episcopalians" - particularly this quote:
Episcopalians don't actually believe in anything, but what's fashionable and easy.
This is not the right use of words - there are a strong, struggling minority of members in the Episcopal Church who work very hard and risk for what they believe.
Rather, it has become what TEC represents - it's what TEC, in its public face, IS. Now, you can take issue with that all you want. I won't argue anymore, I'm just dead inside. But, ask yourself, ask others, if it's not so. For that matter, ask others how much they actually know about us compared to RC's or Evangelicals. We aren't polite or restrained, just milquetoast and vacillating - that's the public reality.
And, now, something completely unrelated, because I give up and silly and cute is better than all the noise:
Tuesday, September 8, 2009
Reality Check
What the hell am I doing?
I'm not that bright. I don't find myself able to converse on anything but my loves of anime and video games - at 41, yet! Nobody listens to anything I've got to say, and, if they did, what good is it? There's nothing there. I've meditated, prayed, read, all for years, and I'm no nearer any kind of enlightenment. I don't see a purpose or place in anything, and I don't embrace a nihilist view that there's nothing to accomplish and nothing to stand for. I've nothing new or useful or even thought-provoking to say. Why am I keeping at this?
I'm not that bright. I don't find myself able to converse on anything but my loves of anime and video games - at 41, yet! Nobody listens to anything I've got to say, and, if they did, what good is it? There's nothing there. I've meditated, prayed, read, all for years, and I'm no nearer any kind of enlightenment. I don't see a purpose or place in anything, and I don't embrace a nihilist view that there's nothing to accomplish and nothing to stand for. I've nothing new or useful or even thought-provoking to say. Why am I keeping at this?
Wednesday, September 2, 2009
Tuesday, September 1, 2009
Some Examples
I've just been too tired and depressed to write much more on my half-formed theory, and appreciate the conversation that we've had so far. I'm working on more, hopefully clarifying and simplifying some of what I'm thinking.
I've found some examples of the things directing my thinking, though.
First, Grandmere Mimi took the bold step of going to Mary Landrieu's town-hall meeting on healthcare - she reports on her experience here and here.
Note in her descriptions the almost-unconscious use of non sequitir by the opponents to national healthcare, the repetition of lies and misinformation fed to them in the face of being told that these "facts" are lies. Note the simplistic inability to comprehend that they might be wrong or misinformed, the inability to comprehend that others don't see absolute truth in all they're saying. Note, also, that, in extremis, they resort to an almost animalistic violence, screaming, threatening, abusing. This is bizarre behavior. The fact that it can be pointed to so often is a vindication, rather than a refutation, of my position that this is an indication of a sort of mental dysfunction in a large group of human beings. We all feel fear, we all have anxiety in the face of change, all defend their positions - I'm doing it now! - but the simple fact is, we see that there are some simply incapable of rising above those feelings to a level of enlightened discourse.
Now, in this example, we have an interview with Nicky Gumbel, the founder of the somewhat-controversial Alpha Course. The interviewer is aggressive, without a doubt, but not, I believe, offensive (for those who doubt it, please look at other examples of British interviews). In response, Gumbel is evasive, to put it kindly. It is clear that his answers are meant to manipulate. It is equally clear that his answers are having no effect on the aggressive interviewer. Gumbel is an example of the clever agent of entropy - keeps dodging and weaving, aiming his message to minds that will be influenced by the basest of arguments. He is aiming it at those who are incapable of questioning, of rising above feelings - "See! He's a nice guy! He says so!" - to enlightened examination.
Finally, we have this article from Chief Rabbi Sir Jonathan Sacks. Sacks' commentary is always thoughtful, frequently challenging, sometimes annoyingly erudite. Specifically, I was moved by the example he gives of Rabbi Shimon Ha-Amsoni. I leave it to you to read the story. The entire article is a description of a wise - an enlightened - approach to knowledge, to our communal cooperation and decision-making, and the story of Rabbi Ha-Amsoni is the consummate example of the sort of evolution of consciousness I've been trying to explain - the ability to live with the experiment, and with the results.
Another example is found here. This is from the "loyal opposition" in relation to me as a Christian believer, yet he shows that ability to think "above," so to speak. He can look in a holistic fashion, outside of his own milieu, and see both the good and the bad, and to question his own approach. While he stays within his own basic convictions, this is not the weakness of intractability, but the strength of real belief. Note, also, his gracious response to some rather snide comments, showing a willingness to engage.
ADDENDUM:
Thanks to Rebecca Nail for bringing this to my attention. It's a fairly well-balanced take on the issue, I think.
I've found some examples of the things directing my thinking, though.
First, Grandmere Mimi took the bold step of going to Mary Landrieu's town-hall meeting on healthcare - she reports on her experience here and here.
Note in her descriptions the almost-unconscious use of non sequitir by the opponents to national healthcare, the repetition of lies and misinformation fed to them in the face of being told that these "facts" are lies. Note the simplistic inability to comprehend that they might be wrong or misinformed, the inability to comprehend that others don't see absolute truth in all they're saying. Note, also, that, in extremis, they resort to an almost animalistic violence, screaming, threatening, abusing. This is bizarre behavior. The fact that it can be pointed to so often is a vindication, rather than a refutation, of my position that this is an indication of a sort of mental dysfunction in a large group of human beings. We all feel fear, we all have anxiety in the face of change, all defend their positions - I'm doing it now! - but the simple fact is, we see that there are some simply incapable of rising above those feelings to a level of enlightened discourse.
Now, in this example, we have an interview with Nicky Gumbel, the founder of the somewhat-controversial Alpha Course. The interviewer is aggressive, without a doubt, but not, I believe, offensive (for those who doubt it, please look at other examples of British interviews). In response, Gumbel is evasive, to put it kindly. It is clear that his answers are meant to manipulate. It is equally clear that his answers are having no effect on the aggressive interviewer. Gumbel is an example of the clever agent of entropy - keeps dodging and weaving, aiming his message to minds that will be influenced by the basest of arguments. He is aiming it at those who are incapable of questioning, of rising above feelings - "See! He's a nice guy! He says so!" - to enlightened examination.
Finally, we have this article from Chief Rabbi Sir Jonathan Sacks. Sacks' commentary is always thoughtful, frequently challenging, sometimes annoyingly erudite. Specifically, I was moved by the example he gives of Rabbi Shimon Ha-Amsoni. I leave it to you to read the story. The entire article is a description of a wise - an enlightened - approach to knowledge, to our communal cooperation and decision-making, and the story of Rabbi Ha-Amsoni is the consummate example of the sort of evolution of consciousness I've been trying to explain - the ability to live with the experiment, and with the results.
Another example is found here. This is from the "loyal opposition" in relation to me as a Christian believer, yet he shows that ability to think "above," so to speak. He can look in a holistic fashion, outside of his own milieu, and see both the good and the bad, and to question his own approach. While he stays within his own basic convictions, this is not the weakness of intractability, but the strength of real belief. Note, also, his gracious response to some rather snide comments, showing a willingness to engage.
ADDENDUM:
Thanks to Rebecca Nail for bringing this to my attention. It's a fairly well-balanced take on the issue, I think.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)