It's about Reality, with the capital "R."
You see, there is no value in a theology that won't stand up to reasonable investigation and testing. The concept that this means that you'd have to prove God or Afterlife or any of that is, at the core, a red herring. These are matters of faith, yes, but neither unprovable nor provable. Reasonably, they can be allowed to remain as they are. No one is objectively harmed by the belief in God or an Afterlife, and no one is objectively harmed by being allowed the option of deciding against such possibilities. They are neutral. Alleged - and I mean alleged - concern on the part of others for any such thing as a soul, while, if real, is admirable, is unwarranted as a justification for action against a freedom which provides no objective harm. Even in faith, we must accept that God understands the nature of this situation, the Reality into which He, Himself, placed us and will not hold us culpable for reasonable theology and action.
Sexuality is the presenting issue, and the facts speak against the "traditional" theology of sexuality. There is objective harm done to homosexuals of faith when faced with this teaching, while there is no objective benefit in embracing that teaching.
Objective Harm:
Forcing oneself into a "marriage" based on a desire to be "normal;"
Feelings of inadequacy or even loss of humanity which leads to:
- Depression
- Suicide
- Risk-taking behavior, often used to stereotype the homosexual "lifestyle" by proponents of this "traditional" theology - not limited to drug usage, sexual promiscuity, self mutilation
In short, a great deal of the "harmful" nature of the homosexual lifestyle can be shown to be either typical of an age group or the direct result of those "traditional" teachings that demonize homosexual attraction and sexual contact.
So, dealt with. The facts on the ground, any reasonable faith, all these speak loudly against and only against the "traditional" religious teachings on homosexuality.
Presenting issues aside, it is an affront to reason to claim as valid argument the premise that someone of an "orthodox" outlook can dismiss the direct experience of a homosexual person's own life, relationship with self and God, history, self-awareness and self-exploration, direct revelation (if one grants the possibility of any revelation from a Divine source) based on writings and hermeneutics applied to a general populace under entirely different conditions with no knowledge of that homosexual person him/herself. If faith requires that we embrace harm, then what we have faith in is wrong. The "orthodox" faith is, therefore, entirely wrong on this issue, and that is the real underlying conflict.
Will we accept a faith that demands we lower ourselves to an animalistic, irresponsible form of life, mindlessly devoted to teachings regardless of their relevance, mindlessly obedient to those who claim to be keepers of those teachings, or will we step up to a life in which we take responsibility for all that is ours to take responsibility for, using the minds and experiences God gave us, the community of common humanity that God bestowed upon us, the gifts of discernment and responsibility that God has created in us, leaving to Him the Mercy and Compassion of which He has assured us, the understanding of our limitations that His Incarnation has brought Him?
Will we trust ourselves to people who claim the necessity of punishment and reward to prevent us from doing things that we know in ourselves to be wrong, and who require mindless wrong on our part because of an all-or-nothing approach based on lack of discernment?
