Thursday, July 24, 2008

Question About Bishops

Trying to streamline and clarify what I asked yesterday.





SERIOUSLY. I WANT REPLIES. BRING FRIENDS, SINCE I TRY TO AVOID BLOG-WHORING.

COME FOR THE APE

STAY FOR THE INPUT!

The questions, excised and trimmed from yesterday's post:



Is it prideful for a "mere layman" to . . .request, or even demand, the information to process the situation and the bishop's response [rather than accepting the bishop's vague reassurances]?

Is it humility, or simple laziness, convenience, or fear that keep us from being more vocal in our opposition to bishops' actions, or, more frequently, inactions?

What is the place of the bishop?
Of the layman?
What are their roles respective to each other?

Is what I (we) have been doing simple bitching and whining, or, in all humility, do we have a right to be included in what our bishops are doing and discussing?

Thank you. I look forward to your answers.

Lambeth Roundup 7/23

My Lambeth Roundup tends to be the mere essentials of what I've lately heard.





Ready?





It was all pretty stupid and, when not bullying Americans or putting Americans down, or generally talking about how subhuman, un-Christian and basically nasty Americans are (and they smell, too), it was bible camp for people who shouldn't need it by now.





Deep theology continues. Send shovels, please.





I have looked at the utter garbage being spewed by a great many outside of TEC and the Americas, the lies and propaganda and the Archbishop of Canterbury-all-Americans! smiling about it and I wonder where our bishops' voices are, raised in protest. Well, there's +Leo from Southeast Florida who corrected some misconceptions and noted the disinformation on his blog and . . .





Well, no "and," really; that's it.


I've come to the conclusion that we're going to stay in the Anglican Communion, not because it's good or helpful, or any of that, but because we Americans like playing at ceremony and dress-up and any number of people will leave if we can't pretend to be a mini-RCC "with branch offices worldwide!" . . . even if it means we crush our consciences into a wall and throw them away.








Two things popped out at me.


First, Ivan Dias, Roman Catholic cardinal addressed the conference. He compared the AC to a Parkinson's sufferer. My response to this was:












For two reasons:

First - Parkinson's? Really, Cardster, ya wanna go there? Little tasteless, mebbe?

Second - Why is a cardinal of the Roman Catholic Church addressing our bishops about Anglican problems? Huh? In short:

Who hired Schmucky the Clown to come and entertain, and can we fire the person who did so (please let it be Rowan, please let it be Rowan!)?

Second:

Remember how Deng said we should immediately cease all actions against the schismatics?

Apparently, that doesn't apply to Deng's church, though. Details

Note who financed the operation, too.


Tuesday, July 22, 2008

Most of Us Have Read Deng's Outrageous Statements

If not here.

Again, I am trying to avoid anger and hatred, so, I give you, again, one of my favorite quotes, from one of my favorite Stoics, Marcus Aurelius:


"Say to yourself in the early morning: I shall meet today ungrateful, violent, treacherous, envious, uncharitable men. All of these things have come upon them through ignorance of real good and ill... I can neither be harmed by any of them, for no man will involve me in wrong, nor can I be angry with my kinsman or hate him; for we have come into the world to work together... "

St. Mary Magdalene

Robert Lentz's icon
Her feast day today, July 22.
All but one of the men ran and hid. The women remained true, even after death.
The weaker sex! (snort)

Yeah! What I said!

This is what I posted to "Gloriman" and "Karen," who were so kind as to respond to my post on Lambeth goings on:

"My problem is that I take a hierarchical church seriously -- I didn't join a church with bishops just for pretty services and a guy or gal in an impressive hat. I don't want a congregational polity, but - and it's an important "but" - I don't want us to repeat the mistakes of the past, assuming unquestioning obedience to bishops. History has conclusively demonstrated the problems there. We must be accountable to the bishop, but the bishop - and this is important I think - must be accountable to us, as well!

We tend to overdo the idea of children in submission to a parental figure; a bishop is as much a child as we are, and, as such, we have every right to expect a LOT more that simply "Well, we've got things going on you don't know about."

Tell us! Convince us, or have the humility to listen to our objections!

Well, that's my little view. :)"


Now, there is more to this than simply being pleased with my own writing: I have been read St. Teresa of Avila's Interior Castle, and, throughout the first four mansions, the recurring theme has been one of humility -- humility above all leads to the heart of that interior castle.

So, have I erred in Pride, here? Is it prideful for a "mere layman" to call out his/her bishop on an issue, to request, or even demand, the information to process the situation and the bishop's response? Is it humility, or simple laziness, convenience, or fear that keep us from being more vocal in our opposition to bishops' actions, or, more frequently, inactions?

These are serious questions, and I value input. I know that I have a few readers, here, and I'm not trying to pump up my readership - what a responsibility, if I had more than my patient and faithful few! - but I would like it if you would ask others if they would be willing to give their view. I hate disrupting others' blogs to "promote" (or the apt sobriquet "blog whore") mine, but it is important to me to get feedback on this, on a personal level, and as a possible preparation for something I think might be a grand, if futile, gesture.

What is the place of the bishop? Of the layman? What are their roles respective to each other? Is what I (we) have been doing simple bitching and whining, or, in all humility, do we have a right to be included in what our bishops are doing and discussing?

Thank you. I look forward to your answers.

Is This How the Reasserters Describe Gays to African Bishops?

Monday, July 21, 2008

The Archbishop of Canterbury's Remarks Do Not Reflect the God We Believe In

I am, honestly, trying to post this without anger, and certainly without hatred.

This is what Rowan Williams, Archbishop of Canterbury, said when asked about his purposeful exclusion of Gene Robinson from the Lambeth Conference:

“The problem we faced within the Anglican matter is that bishops that gather at Lambeth represent not just their dioceses but their participation is part of the fellowship of worldwide Anglican Christians,” he said, in response to a question as to why ecumenical participants from other Christian traditions were present at the conference but not Bishop Robinson. “Where there are bishops whose participation in that worldwide fellowship for one reason or another is questionable that’s the reason for questioning their participation.”

I'm sorry, but the only thing I can take from that is "He is questionable because we question him."

Jim Naughton gave his take on it here while the Anglican Journal's report is here.

Was Williams being deliberately insulting to liberals in general and Americans in particular? If so, kudos! You've done it magnificently, sir!

If not, perhaps you should have some quiet time.

I hear about Williams' wisdom from others, but it is simply wishful thinking. Whatever wisdom he may have at home is totally eclipsed by a painfully obvious disdain and malice toward Americans. It is crippled even further by an obvious desire to acquire power - to arrogate power - to the "Anglican Communion" that it never had and does not, in any way, deserve. His rather transparent question about how well the structures of the communion have worked in the past (is Minns ghost-writing for him, as well?) betrays this power-lust. The structures have worked perfectly - for what the AC was only ever meant to be, a loose confederation of bishops related by a similar ecclesial parentage. A Gentleman's Club, of sort, was all it ever was or ever should be, except, of course, ladies must now be allowed, as well.

Can we afford, before God, to continue to sacrifice true religious conviction and real communion to a political entity? While I applaud the humility of our House of Bishops in enduring the outrageous, if veiled, insults to TEC, but would remind them, even Christ stood up to the money-changers in the Temple. There is neither dishonor nor malice in telling the truth to power, which, of all our bishops -- even our presiding bishop -- only the ONE excluded has been willing to do so.

Why have you forsaken us, who should be our caretakers and pastors, protectors as well as teachers?

Why have you betrayed our trust in you?

And why do I bother? Who will even read this? I'm just a pew sitter, no priest, no bishop, not wealthy, not a powerhouse of "doing, doing, doing" in my parish or diocese, not worth listening to because I'm not "normal."

Who will even read it?

Believe it or not, Gene, I know how you feel.

UPDATE:

I added Louie Crew's Files on the various bishops to the list on the left of the page.

I think we all need to keep track of what our bishops are doing.

I welcome any other sources of such information, as our Diocesan sites tend to be extremely bland and supremely uninformative.