First, I don't want to discuss the Synod's decision. It's depressing, and disheartening, and others have it on their blogs.
Second, this week gives me two of my favorite difficult readings. Sunday night, we had Matthew 22:1-14(
Link) while Monday gives us 1 Samuel 15:1-3,7-23(
Link).
The Gospel reading I can come up with many facile interpretations of, but I prefer to
lectio my
divina on that one for a bit.
The other, God, through Samuel, tells Saul to destroy everything and everyone among the Amalekites "men and women, children and infants," even the livestock! Saul spares King Agag and the fattest and best of the livestock, ostensibly as offerings to God. God withdraws his support from Saul for this, Samuel is enraged. In the end, Samuel speaks something like a malediction against Saul (the parallels of divination with rebellion and stubborness with idolatry are an interesting theological statement in themselves).
On one level, its pretty ghastly. God -- yes God! -- tells Saul to kill
every living thing among the Amalekites. That's monstrous to the modern mind. I'm tempted to think, on a purely literal level, that this may have been Samuel, more than God. Surely, God wouldn't do something like this? Why, even, would such a thing be included in Scripture, if you accept, as I do, that it's there for a reason and can be found to contain something.
Dogmatically, it's easy -- don't disobey God's chosen spokesmen NO MATTER WHAT!!!!
That's a message we get a lot, lately. Obsessively, really. And, certainly, scripture speaks to the community, in my opinion, in this reading. What we have is a leader who, while professing his faith in God, refuses to "cut off" all that comes of a bad past (remember, the Israelites are coming back to get rid of a group behind them that's tripped them up before); he hangs on to it, out of fear? self-glorification? obsessiveness? -- we don't really know why Saul did it. He says it was to the Glory of God, but his setting up his own monument, as well as Samuel's dig about being "small in his own eyes," one wonders. In any case, it does remind me, at least, of some of our leadership, and the foot-dragging in certain areas. Sometimes, as Jesus reminded us, the health of the body requires the removal of the corrupted part -- not part, or the gangrene still spreads. This is a group we
know to have been dangerous in the past, and bad leaven can leaven the lump, as well. I think some leaders speak out of fear, when what they
say is "charity" and "brotherhood" and "communion."
Yet, that reading is easy, too. What does it say for me? We move forward in our faith. Sometimes we can't be rid of those things that we stumbled over in the past, some sin, some habit, until we are stronger in our faith, established in our
ascesis. But, then, we must, from our strength, cut away that former stumbling-stone. We can't say, "Oh, I'll just keep
this part . . . it's harmless!" or "Oh, I can transform this into something great!" We have to go back and wipe it all out, whatever this habit or mind or action or association is. "Kill your darlings," our creative fiction professor told us -- how much moreso in the battles of self-dominance. If we leave these "darlings," we leave a subtle path to the old behavior. Agag doesn't seem to have been particularly vile, the sheep and cattle were the best, but they were the "old enemy." In the same way, those things we do/don't, will/won't for God tilt us, inevitably, away from
one path, always fighting a two-front war. If we leave this enemy in our selves then we, like Saul, cannot command, cannot rule, our selves.